The CardBoard
Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - Printable Version

+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? (/thread-3223.html)

Pages: 1 2

Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - fullmetal - 04-13-2012

Bobby Petrino had 158 other applicants for a job that he hired Jessica Dorrell to fill--among the other applicants were highly-qualified football people, a NASA rocket scientist, and a former Cal grad who had worked in the Stanford recruiting office:

Quote:• Christianne Harder, a Cal grad who has worked in the recruiting offices at Stanford and Washington and who currently consults for Western Kentucky's football program.

The Andy Staples article is linked here--one-pager and worth a read.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - unclechuck - 04-14-2012

Interesting article FM; thanks for the link.

I enjoyed the expansion on the NASA guy. A nice slice of life kind of thing.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - washingtonismoney - 04-16-2012

Harder writes in SI: http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2012/football/ncaa/04/16/harder.editorial/index.html

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - jayasena - 04-16-2012

(04-16-2012, 10:17 AM)washingtonismoney link Wrote:Harder writes in SI: http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2012/football/ncaa/04/16/harder.editorial/index.html

Harder: "Jessica Dorrell just screwed me."

Unfortunate choice of expression, methinks.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - yvonne - 04-16-2012

I think it was intentional.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - Roberton3 - 04-16-2012

(04-16-2012, 10:17 AM)washingtonismoney link Wrote:Harder writes in SI: http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2012/football/ncaa/04/16/harder.editorial/index.html

It's interesting that Harder seems to be laying the blame squarely on Dorrell.  It strikes me that Petrino is at least much at fault.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - fullmetal - 04-16-2012

Dorrell gets the blame for not considering what effect her actions might have on the rest of women working in male-dominated sports...but my guess is that Dorrell wasn't considering very much in the way of long-term consequences in the first place.  Harder's article wasn't really concerned with the fact that Dorrell displaced her candidacy but with the fact that this case is now having a chilling effect on all potential women hires in male-dominated coaching staffs.

At least, that's how I read it.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - Roberton3 - 04-16-2012

(04-16-2012, 03:45 PM)fullmetal link Wrote:Dorrell gets the blame for not considering what effect her actions might have on the rest of women working in male-dominated sports...but my guess is that Dorrell wasn't considering very much in the way of long-term consequences in the first place.  Harder's article wasn't really concerned with the fact that Dorrell displaced her candidacy but with the fact that this case is now having a chilling effect on all potential women hires in male-dominated coaching staffs.

At least, that's how I read it.

I read it the same way.  My point was that Harder seems to be putting all of the blame on Dorrell for the negative effects this incident has, whereas I think Petrino deserves at least as much of the blame.  Dorrell and Petrino together did a ton of damage to all women working in male-dominated sports, and yet Harder is criticizing only Dorrell for that.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - CompSci87 - 04-16-2012

There is plenty of blame to go around in this case. The fact that Petrino was blameworthy doesn't make Dorrell any less so, and vice versa.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - fullmetal - 04-17-2012

Blame in $EC scandals is not a zero-sum game...awesome :p

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - oman - 04-17-2012

It feels a bit misplaced.  Most people who get jobs really aren't the absolutely most qualified.  Many people who get jobs get them because they have an "in".  People who improperly give and accept jobs to peole they are romantically attached or attracted to always they they can keep the relatinship quiet or get out of it quietly. 

Mostly, people don't base their hiring decisions on one-off issues like this.

All that being said, I doubt a smart, attractive, athletic woman like Harder is going to be seriously disadvantaged in her job searches in the future.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - fullmetal - 04-17-2012

I agree with most of what you said except the last part about Harder being disadvantaged in future job searches--the article itself states that a dinner Harder was supposed to have with the coach of another program was cancelled because of the Petrino scandal.  I think all networking events that aren't public between male coaches in positions of authority and women prospective hires will suffer a chilling effect.  There are ways to work around it--coaches can bring their spouses or significant others, but still, there's a new obstacle to deal with.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - oman - 04-17-2012

Eh, this is high profile I will admit.  But its not an issue that is new to powerful executives or university officials or any other powerful manager who has the chance to hire an attractive person of the opposite sex in a positioin of relatively little authority.

Attractive people have an edge.  Employers, including football programs, are still going to have to diversity their hires or else be subject to discrimination lawsuits.  The chilling effect may be a surface action, but it won't affect the ultimate hires.

So the interview won't be at the romantic bistro.  In the article it doesn't indicate whether they eventually did or will meet, or whether the discussion they had about current issues may have actually helped Harder with the opportunity.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - oman - 04-17-2012

Okay, I'll be honest, I am kind of curious as to when my rep will spill, if ever, into the positive, but come on...

What did I say to deserve another -1?


Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - yvonne - 04-17-2012

I do not see any -1 on any of your posts in this thread. Perhaps the rater made a mistake and went back and corrected it.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - oman - 04-17-2012

Thanks.  Now I know what the number is!

I guess someone just must have recently read one of my pasts posts and gotten a rise out of it.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - fullmetal - 04-17-2012

oman, I know what you mean about substantive barriers and this not being a directly substantive barrier, but I think it affects the way women approach the task of finding a job in such an atmosphere, and I'm willing to give Harder the benefit of the doubt when she says that things just got harder now that more caution and due diligence is being applied to this kind of job search.  I mean, I'm also tempted to say 'no big deal,' but I'm not in their shoes...ah well.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - oman - 04-18-2012

Someone is being really overly sweet. 

Like my stanford admissions officer overly sweet.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - fullmetal - 04-18-2012

I'm speaking as someone who has experienced discrimination before and may possibly experience discrimination in the future.

Re: Who did Jessica Dorrell beat out for that job? - oman - 04-19-2012

(04-18-2012, 03:00 PM)fullmetal link Wrote:I'm speaking as someone who has experienced discrimination before and may possibly experience discrimination in the future.

Did you think my prior post was directed at your post fullmetal?  I was addressing it to the fact that someone (someone being sweet) had given me positive rep and I was posed to enter positive territory.