The CardBoard
Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - Printable Version

+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL (/thread-12767.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - FarmBoy - 09-30-2016

Quote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - FarmBoy - 09-30-2016

Quote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - 82 Card - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 01:52 AM)norcard link Wrote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Which Stanford player are you accusing of being a persistent head hunter?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - 82 Card - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 01:52 AM)norcard link Wrote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Which Stanford player are you accusing of being a persistent head hunter?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - 82 Card - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 01:52 AM)norcard link Wrote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Which Stanford player are you accusing of being a persistent head hunter?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - CornFed - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 05:10 AM)OutsiderFan link Wrote:[quote author=norcard link=topic=15811.msg173875#msg173875 date=1475225555]
Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

I don't remember too many Stanford players making illegal hits.  There was this Shayne Skov hit on Jared Goff in the helmet area a couple years ago, but I don't think he was concussed.  Nevertheless, given today's rules, and what we are advocating against, it should have been flagged.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HeWnGeY9gw4
[/quote]

The hit by Skov has come up w/ my friends almost every time I have expressed my disgust w/ the hit on Owusu.  Most of them are not even Cal supporters.  That hit by Skov was several years ago, but people remember it.

I don't think the poster's question says anything specific about repeat offenses and that is an aspect w/ Goodman that shows a very ugly side of football.  He has been shown to be a vicious player intent on doing serious damage to other players.  Skov had that one outlier on Goff, but the rest of his career demonstrated that the Goff hit was an exception and that Skov was not a dirty player.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - CornFed - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 05:10 AM)OutsiderFan link Wrote:[quote author=norcard link=topic=15811.msg173875#msg173875 date=1475225555]
Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

I don't remember too many Stanford players making illegal hits.  There was this Shayne Skov hit on Jared Goff in the helmet area a couple years ago, but I don't think he was concussed.  Nevertheless, given today's rules, and what we are advocating against, it should have been flagged.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HeWnGeY9gw4
[/quote]

The hit by Skov has come up w/ my friends almost every time I have expressed my disgust w/ the hit on Owusu.  Most of them are not even Cal supporters.  That hit by Skov was several years ago, but people remember it.

I don't think the poster's question says anything specific about repeat offenses and that is an aspect w/ Goodman that shows a very ugly side of football.  He has been shown to be a vicious player intent on doing serious damage to other players.  Skov had that one outlier on Goff, but the rest of his career demonstrated that the Goff hit was an exception and that Skov was not a dirty player.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - CornFed - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 05:10 AM)OutsiderFan link Wrote:[quote author=norcard link=topic=15811.msg173875#msg173875 date=1475225555]
Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

I don't remember too many Stanford players making illegal hits.  There was this Shayne Skov hit on Jared Goff in the helmet area a couple years ago, but I don't think he was concussed.  Nevertheless, given today's rules, and what we are advocating against, it should have been flagged.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HeWnGeY9gw4
[/quote]

The hit by Skov has come up w/ my friends almost every time I have expressed my disgust w/ the hit on Owusu.  Most of them are not even Cal supporters.  That hit by Skov was several years ago, but people remember it.

I don't think the poster's question says anything specific about repeat offenses and that is an aspect w/ Goodman that shows a very ugly side of football.  He has been shown to be a vicious player intent on doing serious damage to other players.  Skov had that one outlier on Goff, but the rest of his career demonstrated that the Goff hit was an exception and that Skov was not a dirty player.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - SUBuddha - 09-30-2016

To be completely honest, I don't think John Lynch's style of play would have been conducive to the current climate. Many of his hits in college and the pros could be construed as targeting.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - SUBuddha - 09-30-2016

To be completely honest, I don't think John Lynch's style of play would have been conducive to the current climate. Many of his hits in college and the pros could be construed as targeting.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - SUBuddha - 09-30-2016

To be completely honest, I don't think John Lynch's style of play would have been conducive to the current climate. Many of his hits in college and the pros could be construed as targeting.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - norcard - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 05:23 AM)FarmBoy link Wrote:
Quote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - norcard - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 05:23 AM)FarmBoy link Wrote:
Quote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - norcard - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 05:23 AM)FarmBoy link Wrote:
Quote:Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - FarmBoy - 09-30-2016

Quote:Quote from: FarmBoy on Today at 05:23:32 am
Quote
Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

So I guess I should take that as a "no", you don't know what is involved in being a fan?

This is the week after the game, I think it's fair to lament the hit for a few days, especially in the light of the news he'll miss our upcoming match against a Pac12 North rival and in light of the additional communications from the Pac12 that folks posted here. If you don't like discussing the good, the bad, and the ugly of Stanford sports, perhaps you're in the wrong place.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - FarmBoy - 09-30-2016

Quote:Quote from: FarmBoy on Today at 05:23:32 am
Quote
Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

So I guess I should take that as a "no", you don't know what is involved in being a fan?

This is the week after the game, I think it's fair to lament the hit for a few days, especially in the light of the news he'll miss our upcoming match against a Pac12 North rival and in light of the additional communications from the Pac12 that folks posted here. If you don't like discussing the good, the bad, and the ugly of Stanford sports, perhaps you're in the wrong place.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - FarmBoy - 09-30-2016

Quote:Quote from: FarmBoy on Today at 05:23:32 am
Quote
Are you guys this diligent when a stanford player lays out another player?

Have you ever seen a fanbase defend opponents as much as they defend players on their own team? Do you understand what being a fan is about?

Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

So I guess I should take that as a "no", you don't know what is involved in being a fan?

This is the week after the game, I think it's fair to lament the hit for a few days, especially in the light of the news he'll miss our upcoming match against a Pac12 North rival and in light of the additional communications from the Pac12 that folks posted here. If you don't like discussing the good, the bad, and the ugly of Stanford sports, perhaps you're in the wrong place.

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - BostonCard - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 09:46 AM)norcard link Wrote:Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

If it bothers you so much, you may want to just ignore this thread.

BC

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - BostonCard - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 09:46 AM)norcard link Wrote:Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

If it bothers you so much, you may want to just ignore this thread.

BC

Re: Pac-12 Says Goodman Hit on Owusu was LEGAL - BostonCard - 09-30-2016

(09-30-2016, 09:46 AM)norcard link Wrote:Take off the rose colored glasses that have been stained brown.  Our players are not infallible when it comes to vicious hits either (even non-helmet to helmet ones).  Do you remember how much the team celebrated when we pretty much separated Conor Halliday's shoulder a few years back?  The Goodman hit was illegal - Shaw has already reached out to the office.  There's no point in bantering about it continuously anymore.  It already has national coverage with disdain.  Move on. Or is that not a concept you can comprehend?

If it bothers you so much, you may want to just ignore this thread.

BC