Giants now worse than 2017? - Printable Version
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Giants now worse than 2017? (/thread-15886.html)
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Giants now worse than 2017? (/thread-15886.html)
Giants now worse than 2017? - OutsiderFan - 04-18-2018
Sure, the Giants now have the same 6-10 record they did through 16 games in 2017. The difference is, in 2017 they had five games in which they scored 1 or fewer runs through the first 16 games. This season they have NINE such games, after being shutout last night for the 4th time in 16 games to start 2018.
This, as most of us suggested, is a terrible baseball team that needs to be blown up. And so much for all that leading MLB in Spring training offensive iron pyrite. The Giants are tied with the Royals for the fewest runs scored (46) in MLB, but the Giants are the worst, because they have played one more game than KC. Their pitching is better than some teams, but it's not going to be good enough to even sniff wild card contention when the offense can't even muster 3 RPG. So what's the point of trying with an old team that has no future upside?
One other note: The Giants have only so far played one team with a top 12 best record in MLB, in the D-Backs. Their next 12 games are against Arizona, Anaheim, Washington, and the Dodgers who are starting to get it together.
IOW, the season is OVER. Just pack it in and start rebuilding, as every knowledgeable Giants fan suggested after the 2017 season debacle.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - Phogge - 04-18-2018
The biggest opportunity was getting viable prospects by trading Bumgarner. Larry Baer is knocked kneed scared of alienating fans by anything that smells of rebuild.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - OutsiderFan - 04-18-2018
Well, many, maybe even most Giants fans are alienated by trying to put lipstick on this pig of team and telling us it's a beauty queen contest contender. The only thing this team is good for in the pig metaphor, is a trip to the slaughterhouse. At least then you can get some bacon, pork chops, shoulder, and ribs from it that someone might want to buy.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - BostonCard - 04-18-2018
Not just a shutout yesterday, but a one-hit shutout where the no-hit bid was ended with an eighth inning infield single. Ugh.
BC
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - qwerty49 - 04-18-2018
(04-18-2018, 11:13 AM)Boston Card link Wrote: Not just a shutout yesterday, but a one-hit shutout where the no-hit bid was ended with an eighth inning infield single. Ugh.
BC
And that was on a check swing roller to the left side against the shift. It doesnt get much weaker than that.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - Phogge - 04-18-2018
They will soon bring up Mac Williamson who is crushing it in Sacto.
Of course hell go 2-25 with thirteen strikeouts in his first week back.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - BobK - 04-18-2018
I will never give up ððð»ð
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - winflop - 04-18-2018
I'm a life-long die hard Cubs fan (is there any other kind?).
Hey Giants fans - boo friggin hoo. Cry me a river. You've celebrated 3 World Championships this decade.
Good on you Bob sticking with your team through thick and thin.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - Papa John - 04-18-2018
After tonight's blown-save-extra-innings-home-run-almost-another-blown-save win over the Diamondbacks, the Giants are only three games back in the wildcard chase...
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - lex24 - 04-18-2018
Agree with your general proposition on Baer. But I still hope they never trade either Bum or Posey.
(04-18-2018, 06:50 AM)Phogge link Wrote: The biggest opportunity was getting viable prospects by trading Bumgarner. Larry Baer is knocked kneed scared of alienating fans by anything that smells of rebuild.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - lex24 - 04-18-2018
Just because I think they stink doesnt mean Im not sticking with them. And over my 55 plus years of fandom there has been a far share of thin.
(04-18-2018, 07:12 PM)winflop link Wrote: I'm a life-long die hard Cubs fan (is there any other kind?).
Hey Giants fans - boo friggin hoo. Cry me a river. You've celebrated 3 World Championships this decade.
Good on you Bob sticking with your team through thick and thin.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - donkey687 - 04-19-2018
Giants will be fine. They will be flirting with .500 much of the season and may be sniffing a wild card until September. Their early season schedule hasn't been easy. There are a lot of teams that stink and are tanking it that the Giants are better than. Stratton and Cueto are pitching very well. MadBum will be back. Despite slow starts McCutcheon and Longoria are professional hitters and good fielders. This team is a lot better than last year.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - Mick - 04-19-2018
(04-18-2018, 04:57 PM)Phogge link Wrote: They will soon bring up Mac Williamson who is crushing it in Sacto.
Of course hell go 2-25 with thirteen sixteen strikeouts in his first week back.
Fixed it for you. ;D
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - BobK - 04-19-2018
It took this give Up ð thread to have Belt to finally get a clutch hit. IT worked. Plus torture is back
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - Phogge - 04-19-2018
Bobbb, I was there for Game 1 in 1958, albeit on a press pass loading mags for my father. There have been lots of ups and lots of downs.
I reserve the right under a variety of Constitutional guarantees and secret CIA memos to cry WOLF on the Giants scouting department.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - BobK - 04-19-2018
I was still bemoaning the loss of my beloved Seals.Â
Then Ruben made the first pitch and it was Giants forever
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - gocard14 - 04-19-2018
I'm still cautiously optimistic. The Giants are 7-10 despite hitting very poorly as a team. Cutch, Longoria, Pence, and Crawford are all likely to improve from the plate just from regression to the mean. The bullpen is playing pretty well and Cueto and Stratton have been great. If they can keep it up the Giants will have a good rotation once Bumgarner and Smarzdija return. They just need to find a way to play near .500 ball until then.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - BobK - 04-19-2018
Smarzdija pitched at San Jose the other day. Not well but he did pitch several innings
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - wallendar - 04-19-2018
Joe Garagiola once said, You get one Social Security number and one baseball team. Mine is the Giants - from the day my parents let me stay home from school to listen to Ruben Gomez toss a shutout v. the Bums to the present, Ive been with them - Giants forever....Â
As for this season, I dont think we can accurately assess their chances until the 40 game mark. It takes 25% of the season to get a real handle on things.
Re: Giants now worse than 2017? - Mick - 04-19-2018
(04-19-2018, 08:32 AM)Phogge link Wrote: Bobbb, I was there for Game 1 in 1958, albeit on a press pass loading mags for my father. There have been lots of ups and lots of downs.
I reserve the right under a variety of Constitutional guarantees and secret CIA memos to cry WOLF on the Giants scouting department.
Well, way more ups than downs. The Giants have won the most games in the history of professional sports. They're the only MLB franchise that has won more than 11,000 games. They have the second highest winning percentage in MLB at .536 (11,022 wins against 9,523 losses).