[CrazedZooChimp]

[quote author=ferrari link=topic=12165.msg119068#msg119068 date=1432672433]
[quote author=oldalum link=topic=12165.msg119063#msg119063 date=1432671197]
Academic qualifications aside, it seems somehow wrong to have zero players from the U.S. competing on a U.S. college team. The issue afflicts other college sports such as tennis. As I recall when Stanford W tennis won the championship 2 years ago, our championship opponent Texas A&M had zero players from the U.S. on its team.

Seems pretty parochial to me, if not a bit of sour grapes.  Why wouldn't your opinion apply to states as well?  Only California kids at California schools, for example.  No damn foreigners!
[/quote]

I think there is something to be said for student athletes to be generally representative of the students at your institution.  I think a blanket prohibition against foreigners would be bad, but just as of exceedingly large proportions discrepencies between the academic qualifications and graduation rates of student athletes and students writ large at certain schools might raise an eyebrow, likewise, a big disparity in the foreign origin of athletes versus all students might make you wonder if they are really student-athletes or hired guns.

BC
[/quote]


As long as the attitude doesn't apply to PhD students or professorships too, because then we might have to lose a few departments that probably bring in a lot more money to Stanford than women's golf does...

[CrazedZooChimp]

[quote author=ferrari link=topic=12165.msg119068#msg119068 date=1432672433]
[quote author=oldalum link=topic=12165.msg119063#msg119063 date=1432671197]
Academic qualifications aside, it seems somehow wrong to have zero players from the U.S. competing on a U.S. college team. The issue afflicts other college sports such as tennis. As I recall when Stanford W tennis won the championship 2 years ago, our championship opponent Texas A&M had zero players from the U.S. on its team.

Seems pretty parochial to me, if not a bit of sour grapes.  Why wouldn't your opinion apply to states as well?  Only California kids at California schools, for example.  No damn foreigners!
[/quote]

I think there is something to be said for student athletes to be generally representative of the students at your institution.  I think a blanket prohibition against foreigners would be bad, but just as of exceedingly large proportions discrepencies between the academic qualifications and graduation rates of student athletes and students writ large at certain schools might raise an eyebrow, likewise, a big disparity in the foreign origin of athletes versus all students might make you wonder if they are really student-athletes or hired guns.

BC
[/quote]


As long as the attitude doesn't apply to PhD students or professorships too, because then we might have to lose a few departments that probably bring in a lot more money to Stanford than women's golf does...