[TrumpCard]

Director's Cup hypothetical*


School A wins the Director's Cup by 20 points.  School B comes in second.  20+ years later, a scandal erupts regarding pervasive academic fraud infecting multiple sports for many years at School A.  Based on the findings of an NCAA investigation, it is determined that a number of players on School A's teams were ineligible, and, as a result, the wins by School A's teams wins are vacated.  If the Director's Cup were re-scored with School A the losing points scored by the teams that had their wins vacated, then School B would have more total points. 


Questions:
Does School A have the Director's Cup vacated?  (I think yes)
Does School B win the Director's Cup retroactively?  (I think no)



*Note:  Of course, I am referring to UNC's win in the first year of the Cup.  I would like to be able to say that no other school has ever won the Cup, even if I have to put an asterisk at the end of that sentence.

[TrumpCard]

Director's Cup hypothetical*


School A wins the Director's Cup by 20 points.  School B comes in second.  20+ years later, a scandal erupts regarding pervasive academic fraud infecting multiple sports for many years at School A.  Based on the findings of an NCAA investigation, it is determined that a number of players on School A's teams were ineligible, and, as a result, the wins by School A's teams wins are vacated.  If the Director's Cup were re-scored with School A the losing points scored by the teams that had their wins vacated, then School B would have more total points. 


Questions:
Does School A have the Director's Cup vacated?  (I think yes)
Does School B win the Director's Cup retroactively?  (I think no)



*Note:  Of course, I am referring to UNC's win in the first year of the Cup.  I would like to be able to say that no other school has ever won the Cup, even if I have to put an asterisk at the end of that sentence.