[Rally]

[quote author=OutsiderFan link=topic=13922.msg146015#msg146015 date=1449379905]
My words:

Even more deserving of Voldemort than Toby Gerhart.  It would be a travesty if McCaffrey doesn't win it.  The ONLY thing he didn't do this year is return a punt for a TD.  But the stats, versatility, durability, and value to his team is off the charts.

1. CMac
2. Derek Henry
3. Deshaun Watson

Give Henry the Doak Walker.  He is probably a better RB but not by a lot.  Watson isn't even in the top 10 in QBR, but he is the leader of an undefeated team.  McCaffrey is the hands-down best PLAYER in CFB this year.
[/quote]

Best running back . . . "But not by a lot" is putting it mildly.  Henry 5.9 ypc, McCaffrey 5.8 ypc.  To call Henry the best player assumes McCaffrey played patsies all year, which is what I read several rabid SECers write.  The only thing I haven't heard/read is the race card which was sparingly used against Toby.

[Rally]

[quote author=OutsiderFan link=topic=13922.msg146015#msg146015 date=1449379905]
My words:

Even more deserving of Voldemort than Toby Gerhart.  It would be a travesty if McCaffrey doesn't win it.  The ONLY thing he didn't do this year is return a punt for a TD.  But the stats, versatility, durability, and value to his team is off the charts.

1. CMac
2. Derek Henry
3. Deshaun Watson

Give Henry the Doak Walker.  He is probably a better RB but not by a lot.  Watson isn't even in the top 10 in QBR, but he is the leader of an undefeated team.  McCaffrey is the hands-down best PLAYER in CFB this year.
[/quote]

Best running back . . . "But not by a lot" is putting it mildly.  Henry 5.9 ypc, McCaffrey 5.8 ypc.  To call Henry the best player assumes McCaffrey played patsies all year, which is what I read several rabid SECers write.  The only thing I haven't heard/read is the race card which was sparingly used against Toby.