[Rally]

I'm not too sure what your gripe is.  McCaffrey's rushing stats in his bowl game paled in comparison to the two RBs who got the nod, but his all-purpose exploits were rightly recognized.

Are you addressing me?  The AA lists I was referring to are NOT "best bowl performance " lists, but presumably for the season.  Do you care to list 6 running backs from the just-ended season better than McCaffrey?  And if you want, feel free to disregard receiving yards, even tho running backs are usually expected to catch a ball now and then.  Or, as Terry rightly says, "
Why should we look only at rushing stats to evaluate running backs? Catching the ball also is part of being a running back." If you are not addressing me, then all right then.

EDIT TO ADD. Okay, I see now the original thread regarded all bowl team.  So, forget about dissing receiving yards.  Running backs are expected to do three things, four if you're McCaffrey:  run, catch, block, and throw a pass now and then.  Go ahead, defend your guys.

Start with only rushing yards.  Henry, 158 on 36 carries; McCaffrey 172 on 18 carries.  Your turn.

[Rally]

I'm not too sure what your gripe is.  McCaffrey's rushing stats in his bowl game paled in comparison to the two RBs who got the nod, but his all-purpose exploits were rightly recognized.

Are you addressing me?  The AA lists I was referring to are NOT "best bowl performance " lists, but presumably for the season.  Do you care to list 6 running backs from the just-ended season better than McCaffrey?  And if you want, feel free to disregard receiving yards, even tho running backs are usually expected to catch a ball now and then.  Or, as Terry rightly says, "
Why should we look only at rushing stats to evaluate running backs? Catching the ball also is part of being a running back." If you are not addressing me, then all right then.

EDIT TO ADD. Okay, I see now the original thread regarded all bowl team.  So, forget about dissing receiving yards.  Running backs are expected to do three things, four if you're McCaffrey:  run, catch, block, and throw a pass now and then.  Go ahead, defend your guys.

Start with only rushing yards.  Henry, 158 on 36 carries; McCaffrey 172 on 18 carries.  Your turn.