[OutsiderFan]

[quote author=OutsiderFan link=topic=17081.msg196879#msg196879 date=1502381686]
...

Disagree with Love being that important.  Behind Love are Scarlett, Speights, Maddox, and then even Lund and Wedington.  All the RBs looked good in Spring, and Lund and Wedington are elite recruits at the easiest position in football to play early. Behind Phillips is maybe Peek and maybe Dalyn Wade-Perry?  Williams and Swann aren't big enough to play NT, IMO. 

Stanford could lose Love and still win big.  Lose Phillips and championship possibilities likely end.

I disagree with your disagreement.  Love is special.  I feel much better about him going into his first year as "the guy" than I did about Tyler Gaffney or Stepfan Taylor, and they worked out okay.
[/quote]

You honestly believe Stanford is more likely to win a championship if it has Love playing and Phillips not playing, than it is to have Phillips playing and Love not playing?  Really?  Seriously?

[OutsiderFan]

[quote author=OutsiderFan link=topic=17081.msg196879#msg196879 date=1502381686]
...

Disagree with Love being that important.  Behind Love are Scarlett, Speights, Maddox, and then even Lund and Wedington.  All the RBs looked good in Spring, and Lund and Wedington are elite recruits at the easiest position in football to play early. Behind Phillips is maybe Peek and maybe Dalyn Wade-Perry?  Williams and Swann aren't big enough to play NT, IMO. 

Stanford could lose Love and still win big.  Lose Phillips and championship possibilities likely end.

I disagree with your disagreement.  Love is special.  I feel much better about him going into his first year as "the guy" than I did about Tyler Gaffney or Stepfan Taylor, and they worked out okay.
[/quote]

You honestly believe Stanford is more likely to win a championship if it has Love playing and Phillips not playing, than it is to have Phillips playing and Love not playing?  Really?  Seriously?