[winflop]

If you're going on Stanford record alone, McDowell > Mussina. McDowell was conference freshman of the year and a two-time All American. Also was #1 pitcher on the '87 national championship team. Mussina was never an All American.

Arguments could be made for Mark Appel or Jeremy Guthrie, who were the only other two-time All Americans at pitcher.

I'll give the nod to McDowell for winning a natty.

[winflop]

If you're going on Stanford record alone, McDowell > Mussina. McDowell was conference freshman of the year and a two-time All American. Also was #1 pitcher on the '87 national championship team. Mussina was never an All American.

Arguments could be made for Mark Appel or Jeremy Guthrie, who were the only other two-time All Americans at pitcher.

I'll give the nod to McDowell for winning a natty.