[BostonCard]

I'm curious to see if he makes 2nd team all Pac-12 QB. Minshew seems to have the first team slot locked up.  Then it's between Herbert, Browning, and Costello.  Costello probably should get the nod as he leads in PER, is #2 in completion %, YPA, Total Yards, and TDs.

Agreed, on the basis of numbers, and how dependent the offense is on him, he should be a lock to be second team all-PAC-12 (and has a case to be make for an edge over Minshew as first teamer).

There is no way that Herbert should be competitive with Costello.  In one fewer games, Costello has: more completions, a higher completion percentage, more yards, a higher yards per attempt, the same number of touchdowns, and a higher pass efficiency rating.  The only advantage Herbert has over Costello is fewer interceptions.

Likewise, compared to Browning, Costello has more completions, a higher completion percentage, more yards, more touchdowns, and a higher pass efficiency rating.  Browning has a small edge in yards per attempt and fewer interceptions (though KJ has thrown more passes, so on a percentage basis, they are almost identical).

BC

[BostonCard]

I'm curious to see if he makes 2nd team all Pac-12 QB. Minshew seems to have the first team slot locked up.  Then it's between Herbert, Browning, and Costello.  Costello probably should get the nod as he leads in PER, is #2 in completion %, YPA, Total Yards, and TDs.

Agreed, on the basis of numbers, and how dependent the offense is on him, he should be a lock to be second team all-PAC-12 (and has a case to be make for an edge over Minshew as first teamer).

There is no way that Herbert should be competitive with Costello.  In one fewer games, Costello has: more completions, a higher completion percentage, more yards, a higher yards per attempt, the same number of touchdowns, and a higher pass efficiency rating.  The only advantage Herbert has over Costello is fewer interceptions.

Likewise, compared to Browning, Costello has more completions, a higher completion percentage, more yards, more touchdowns, and a higher pass efficiency rating.  Browning has a small edge in yards per attempt and fewer interceptions (though KJ has thrown more passes, so on a percentage basis, they are almost identical).

BC