[wyattp]

I know this isn't a Niners message board, but, there are some good posters here that are sports fans, so in the aftermath of 0-fer the game on 3rd down, and ONE catch by a WR in 4.5 quarters in the Niners' NFCCG loss:

A) Alex Smith is a legit Championship level QB that with an upgrade in WR talent, can win a Super Bowl with a great defense.
B) Alex Smith is incapable of being a championship level QB, even with a gifted WR corps and a great defense.

My personal belief is the Niners' WRs are dreadful, and based on how well Smith throws to Vernon Davis, he could be much more effective with more talented WRs.  Of course, Andrew Luck didn't have the most elite set of WRs (though relatively, you could argue Luck had a better receivers overall than Smith), and Luck performed fantastically, even against good defenses.

What does everyone think?

Regardless of who does the throwing

Three High Quality TE's + 1.5 WR's > Vernon Davis + half of a 49er WR

[wyattp]

I know this isn't a Niners message board, but, there are some good posters here that are sports fans, so in the aftermath of 0-fer the game on 3rd down, and ONE catch by a WR in 4.5 quarters in the Niners' NFCCG loss:

A) Alex Smith is a legit Championship level QB that with an upgrade in WR talent, can win a Super Bowl with a great defense.
B) Alex Smith is incapable of being a championship level QB, even with a gifted WR corps and a great defense.

My personal belief is the Niners' WRs are dreadful, and based on how well Smith throws to Vernon Davis, he could be much more effective with more talented WRs.  Of course, Andrew Luck didn't have the most elite set of WRs (though relatively, you could argue Luck had a better receivers overall than Smith), and Luck performed fantastically, even against good defenses.

What does everyone think?

Regardless of who does the throwing

Three High Quality TE's + 1.5 WR's > Vernon Davis + half of a 49er WR