11-27-2012, 10:04 AM
Could you do a 6th option of having them linked on the main page AND on a separate recruiting section? I think having them on the main page will drive more ongoing discussion. At the same time, having them grouped together in an easy to find place would be helpful for someone trying to catch up on the the recruiting news for the past year.
This is one of the problems I had with the execution of the Stanford board at ESPN. They post the articles on both the Stanford and Pac12 sections, but when you click on the articles, they have separate comments for the one linked on the Stanford-specific site vs. the one on the Pac12 site. So you don't get the critical mass to have a fruitful conversation because the commenters get divided.
This is one of the problems I had with the execution of the Stanford board at ESPN. They post the articles on both the Stanford and Pac12 sections, but when you click on the articles, they have separate comments for the one linked on the Stanford-specific site vs. the one on the Pac12 site. So you don't get the critical mass to have a fruitful conversation because the commenters get divided.