[pincemob]

I really think Tyler Gaffney should have been a Doak Walker award finalist.  Gaffney faced 8 bowl teams, the most of any players in contention.  In those games he averaged 140 yards per game.

Andre Williams faced 7 bowl teams, averaging 127 yards in those games.  He really padded his stats with outings like 339 yards against ACC-winless NC State, and 295 yards against 1-10 New Mexico State.

Bishop Sankey faced 7 bowl teams, averaging 129 yards in those games.  He padded his stats with outings like 241 yards against Cal, and 208 yards against 1-7 Big 10 doormat Illinois.

I think KaDeem Carey was very deserving based on his stats.  He only faced 5 bowl teams, but averaged 156 yards in those games.  He did get suspended for a game and had some issues though. 

I can't be too mad at the Doak voters though, since they at least had the good sense to give Toby the award in 2009 and not overrated Mark Ingram. 

[pincemob]

I really think Tyler Gaffney should have been a Doak Walker award finalist.  Gaffney faced 8 bowl teams, the most of any players in contention.  In those games he averaged 140 yards per game.

Andre Williams faced 7 bowl teams, averaging 127 yards in those games.  He really padded his stats with outings like 339 yards against ACC-winless NC State, and 295 yards against 1-10 New Mexico State.

Bishop Sankey faced 7 bowl teams, averaging 129 yards in those games.  He padded his stats with outings like 241 yards against Cal, and 208 yards against 1-7 Big 10 doormat Illinois.

I think KaDeem Carey was very deserving based on his stats.  He only faced 5 bowl teams, but averaged 156 yards in those games.  He did get suspended for a game and had some issues though. 

I can't be too mad at the Doak voters though, since they at least had the good sense to give Toby the award in 2009 and not overrated Mark Ingram.