[yvonne]

Seattle Times columnist Bob Condotta is doing a series of the top 10 offensive and defensive UW players of the Pac-10 era (1978-2010).

Who are your offensive picks for the top 10 Cardinal in that era? Who are your defensive picks? Maybe someone will want to keep a spreadsheet and post the tally.

[yvonne]

Seattle Times columnist Bob Condotta is doing a series of the top 10 offensive and defensive UW players of the Pac-10 era (1978-2010).

Who are your offensive picks for the top 10 Cardinal in that era? Who are your defensive picks? Maybe someone will want to keep a spreadsheet and post the tally.

[82lsju]

Offense, skill positions only, off the top of my head:

Glyn Milburn
Darren Nelson
Owen Marecic
Toby Gerhart
Ken Margerum
Troy Walters
Justin Armour
Andrew Luck
Tommy Vardell
Chris Dressel

What about John Elway and Ed McCaffrey?

[82lsju]

Offense, skill positions only, off the top of my head:

Glyn Milburn
Darren Nelson
Owen Marecic
Toby Gerhart
Ken Margerum
Troy Walters
Justin Armour
Andrew Luck
Tommy Vardell
Chris Dressel

What about John Elway and Ed McCaffrey?

[Spiny_Norman]

offense:
Bob Whitfield
Brad Muster
Brian Holloway

defense:
Dave Wyman
John Lynch
Willie Howard
Toi Cook
Darrien Gordon

[Spiny_Norman]

offense:
Bob Whitfield
Brad Muster
Brian Holloway

defense:
Dave Wyman
John Lynch
Willie Howard
Toi Cook
Darrien Gordon

[yvonne]

Offense:
John Elway
Andrew Luck
Bob Whitfield
Glynn Milburn
Chris Dalman
Toby Gerhart
Owen Marecic
Troy Walters
?
?

Defense:
Dave Wyman
John Lynch
Willie Howard
Darrien Gordon
Shayne Skov
?
?
?
?
?

[yvonne]

Offense:
John Elway
Andrew Luck
Bob Whitfield
Glynn Milburn
Chris Dalman
Toby Gerhart
Owen Marecic
Troy Walters
?
?

Defense:
Dave Wyman
John Lynch
Willie Howard
Darrien Gordon
Shayne Skov
?
?
?
?
?

[Spiny_Norman]

Shayne Skov

Yvonne - without reservation I say that Shayne Skov will have his finest moments at Stanford in the Pac 12 vs. the Pac 10.

[Spiny_Norman]

Shayne Skov

Yvonne - without reservation I say that Shayne Skov will have his finest moments at Stanford in the Pac 12 vs. the Pac 10.

[yvonne]

This may be true, but he still participated in the Pac-10 era, and was one of the top 10 defensive players in that era. Would you dispute that Andrew Luck was also one of the top 10 players in the Pac-10 era?

[yvonne]

This may be true, but he still participated in the Pac-10 era, and was one of the top 10 defensive players in that era. Would you dispute that Andrew Luck was also one of the top 10 players in the Pac-10 era?

[Spiny_Norman]

Andrew Luck has the highest winning percentage (.800) among Stanford quarterbacks in school history, was 1st team All Pac 10 and runner up in the Voldemort voting.

Shayne Skov was honorable mention all Pac 10 in his one full season as a starter.  He is very talented and can be the defensive leader of a great Stanford defense (as he was in the Orange Bowl).  But I still don't think he would rank above LBs Gordy Ceresino (his 1978 > Skov's 2010), Dave Wyman, Ron George, Coy Wire or Riall Johnson based on his accomplishments so far.

[Spiny_Norman]

Andrew Luck has the highest winning percentage (.800) among Stanford quarterbacks in school history, was 1st team All Pac 10 and runner up in the Voldemort voting.

Shayne Skov was honorable mention all Pac 10 in his one full season as a starter.  He is very talented and can be the defensive leader of a great Stanford defense (as he was in the Orange Bowl).  But I still don't think he would rank above LBs Gordy Ceresino (his 1978 > Skov's 2010), Dave Wyman, Ron George, Coy Wire or Riall Johnson based on his accomplishments so far.

[yvonne]

So produce your lists, my friend!

[yvonne]

So produce your lists, my friend!

[JeffInCorvallis]

John Elway
Andrew Luck
Darrin Nelson
Steve Stenstrom
Glyn Milburn
Brad Muster
Bob Whitfield
John Lynch
Dave Wyman
Toby Gerhart

[JeffInCorvallis]

John Elway
Andrew Luck
Darrin Nelson
Steve Stenstrom
Glyn Milburn
Brad Muster
Bob Whitfield
John Lynch
Dave Wyman
Toby Gerhart