There will be no college football [playoff] this season - Printable Version
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: Emergency (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-11.html)
+--- Forum: Covid-19 (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-12.html)
+--- Thread: There will be no college football [playoff] this season (/thread-20374.html)
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: Emergency (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-11.html)
+--- Forum: Covid-19 (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-12.html)
+--- Thread: There will be no college football [playoff] this season (/thread-20374.html)
RE: There will be no college football this season - teejers1 - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 10:15 AM)JustAnotherFan Wrote: The Big Ten is canceling their football season. Which means there is absolutely no chance of a college football season this fall. Which means there is no college sports this fall or winter.
https://www.freep.com/story/sports/college/2020/08/10/big-ten-football-voted-cancel-fall-football-season/3334151001/
Woo Hoo!! Another thing to blame on Trump, right guys? [It's hard not to read some posts through that filter . . .].
RE: There will be no college football this season - dabigv13 - 08-10-2020
You're being facetious, but considering how the Southern governors have encouraged masking for the express purpose of controlling the virus to allow CFB to be played, fighting the mask skepticism encouraged by the president, its pretty easy actually to tie the (non)performance of our president to CFB not being played. But I don't really want to talk about Trump so I'll leave it there.
RE: There will be no college football this season - needle - 08-10-2020
Official Big 10 spox refutes story and says there has not been a formal vote to cancel/postpone-until-spring.
I guess it's still possible the Big 10 hasn't made a decision? However, usually a statement like this just means the people at the top want to be able to claim they informed their employees first rather than leaked the info to the press.
https://www.cbssports.com/college-football/news/big-ten-says-no-vote-has-been-held-despite-expectations-league-will-cancel-fall-2020-season/
RE: There will be no college football this season - OutsiderFan - 08-10-2020
We don't have a President right now. We have what should be the POTUS, being a clueless critic blaming others for what is he responsible. It would be like David Shaw bitching about being 4-8, blaming players for being soft, injury prone pussies, and re-tweeting attacks on his OC by Winflop.
This is why I have no interest talking about the POTUS. It's utterly a waste of time, but that doesn't change the fact the College Football season is absolutely being cancelled because the United States government has allowed the country to be overwhelmed by a tiny virus. There is no credible argument to the contrary. If infection rates were low as a result of proper national mitigation efforts, this post wouldn't exist.
I'm not saying we could have totally wiped out the virus, but we absolutely could have been in a position to manage it effectively. There is just far too much evidence across the world to conclude anything else.
RE: There will be no college football this season - dabigv13 - 08-10-2020
I still think things may look good enough in a month that CFB is feasible. Many hot spots have significant community immunity by now. Having 20%ish immunity from prior infection, along with strict masking and appropriate business closures, and you're going to be looking like NYC now, or most of Europe. Travel and close contact still makes CFB relatively higher risk for transmission even as community prevalence falls, so still could get outbreaks on a team.
SoCal ICU and hospitalization numbers are continuing steady drop, though regionally still overall more than at the April peak.
RE: There will be no college football this season - Farm93 - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 10:25 AM)teejers1 Wrote:Can't just blame China since New Zealand, Germany & South Korea all have managed to overcome the "China" virus to still play sports. Korea and New Zealand even have fans in the stands and they are both a lot closer to China than the USA.(08-10-2020, 10:15 AM)JustAnotherFan Wrote: The Big Ten is canceling their football season. Which means there is absolutely no chance of a college football season this fall. Which means there is no college sports this fall or winter.
https://www.freep.com/story/sports/college/2020/08/10/big-ten-football-voted-cancel-fall-football-season/3334151001/
Woo Hoo!! Another thing to blame on Trump, right guys? [It's hard not to read some posts through that filter . . .].
Brazil, Mexico and the USA all have COVID19 deniers and all three have troubling case and death trends. So I would blame the USA situation on pandemic deniers and all of those that enable that denier culture to thrive.
FWIW - I am in the relieved category. There is no way I would be able to enjoy watching Stanford sports if Stanford had student-athletes testing positive at the rates we have seen in MLB. If a Stanford player, coach or administrator died just for Stanford to get a share of ESPN's TV revenue that would have redefined guilty pleasure for me. The postponement is still not official, but I think most college presidents are in my camp. A few million in TV revenue should not be used to justify putting the health of students at risk.
Don't like that perspective then USA citizens have some action items -
1) Crush the curve
2) Get serious about testing & tracing
3) Control the spread with PPE
and then perhaps college sports can return.
Speaking of such things....Next up will be Stanford freshmen on campus in September. If the same big three above are not happening consistently in the USA then I expect Freshmen will be told to stay home in the next ~3 weeks. And there too, it won't be a woo-hoo for me, but more of a Thank God type thing.
I so wish for the freshmen to have a proper freshmen year on campus, but it is very obvious that it won't happen.
The guinea pigs in those GA & FL high schools are demonstrating the challenges of schools in the current USA environment.
Stanford is still slated to open after other major universities. My guess is Stanford can wait to see what happens with colleges and universities opening up in the next few days and then make the call.
But if the GA public school experience is replicated at colleges and universities then I will be relieved if college students are told to stay home. The big concern with college openings would be that a university could have deaths in the faculty and staff if asymptomatic students are roaming around.
RE: There will be no college football this season - JustAnotherFan - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 10:25 AM)teejers1 Wrote:(08-10-2020, 10:15 AM)JustAnotherFan Wrote: The Big Ten is canceling their football season. Which means there is absolutely no chance of a college football season this fall. Which means there is no college sports this fall or winter.
https://www.freep.com/story/sports/college/2020/08/10/big-ten-football-voted-cancel-fall-football-season/3334151001/
Woo Hoo!! Another thing to blame on Trump, right guys? [It's hard not to read some posts through that filter . . .].
No need to blame Trump. Everyone who isn't a Trump supporter recognizes how harmful he's been. Everyone who is a Trump supporter always has someone else to point the finger at. Of course Trump is not SOLELY to blame, and I guess that will be part of his legacy.
lex24 - lex24 - 08-10-2020
If not for this pandemic then for the next one.If not for this pandemic then for the next one.
(08-09-2020, 01:53 PM)needle Wrote:(08-09-2020, 10:19 AM)DenverCard Wrote: And then there's this:
https://www.si.com/college/2020/08/09/ncaa-cardiac-inflamation-coronavirus-myocarditis-concerns
I'm not convinced that heart concerns specifically should be driving the decisions about covid-19 and athletics, but this story definitely is concerning:
https://abcnews.go.com/Sports/wireStory/basketball-player-dies-training-serbia-72234976
Tragic. But no reason to think it’s related.
(08-10-2020, 11:40 AM)JustAnotherFan Wrote:(08-10-2020, 10:25 AM)teejers1 Wrote:(08-10-2020, 10:15 AM)JustAnotherFan Wrote: The Big Ten is canceling their football season. Which means there is absolutely no chance of a college football season this fall. Which means there is no college sports this fall or winter.
https://www.freep.com/story/sports/college/2020/08/10/big-ten-football-voted-cancel-fall-football-season/3334151001/
Woo Hoo!! Another thing to blame on Trump, right guys? [It's hard not to read some posts through that filter . . .].
No need to blame Trump. Everyone who isn't a Trump supporter recognizes how harmful he's been. Everyone who is a Trump supporter always has someone else to point the finger at. Of course Trump is not SOLELY to blame, and I guess that will be part of his legacy.
Actually I blame the world pandemic on its source. Particularly given that there were warnings years ago that these open air markets with their bat meat were a “ticking time bomb”. No question what started this pandemic.NONE. So the “ Wuhan Virus” sounds right to me. Just like MERS, Hong Kong Flu, Spanish Flu, Ebola. Naming pandemics for the region in which they emanate has always need the case. Maher NAILED that one.
There should be enormous world pressure put on China to end these markets. Right? Seems pretty obvious to me. And China should be hit with massive economic sanctions. But by all means, let’s not go there. Instead, lets look at all the f—k ups that have occurred trying to stop or slow this pandemic. It’s kind of like a guy gets shot. And dies from sepsis in the hospital a week later. The suit names the Dr and hospital for negligence. Because you sure as heck aren’t going to get any monetary relief from the guy that is truly to blame.
Can’t say anything negative about China. Just ask Adam Silver.
Is it possible to play a College Football season in the Spring? I’m talking logistically more than anything else. I don’t know if it would be the right thing to do. But hopefully by the spring this things under control. If not- Heck I don’t even want to think about if not.
RE: There will be no college football this season - OutsiderFan - 08-10-2020
China sucks and deserves scorn for not containing the virus, but the fact is it has only less than 85,000 reported infections and less than 5,000 total reported deaths. And yes, wild animal markets should be banned. But so too should the ivory trade and shark fin soup.
The United States and its citizens deserve scorn for not adequately protecting its citizens, with 5,000,000 reported infections and over 160,000 reported deaths.
Both countries are terrible in their own rights.
RE: There will be no college football this season - teejers1 - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 01:11 PM)OutsiderFan Wrote: China sucks and deserves scorn for not containing the virus, but the fact is it has only less than 85,000 reported infections and less than 5,000 total reported deaths. And yes, wild animal markets should be banned. But so too should the ivory trade and shark fin soup.
The United States and its citizens deserve scorn for not adequately protecting its citizens, with 5,000,000 reported infections and over 160,000 reported deaths.
Both countries are terrible in their own rights.
I agree 100% that the US should be doing better in overall numbers AND that a brobdingnagian part of that dysfunction lands on Trump, for his feckless, clueless, pointless "response."
Where I get off the train is that it is ALL Trump's fault or even an overwhelming majority. (But even giving him 50% of the blame should suffice for November purposes, imo, anyway). The track and trace efforts have been a joke; and there is no principled policy coming out of either Sacramento or Santa Clara County (which impacts my life more - indeed, state and county decisions impact the US population day-to-day far more than does federal action).
So yes, Trump is first in the blame line (even before China - which is a bad actor on the world stage, so get used to it) and completely failed when it comes to setting the tone and getting the citizenry's "head right" about the gravity of the situation. (And I think beyond tone, the feds could have helped ensure the $$ needed for decent test and trace at local levels). But test and trace is at bottom a local matter, and that, too, has been an utter fail.
RE: There will be no college football this season - oregontim - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 10:25 AM)teejers1 Wrote:(08-10-2020, 10:15 AM)JustAnotherFan Wrote: The Big Ten is canceling their football season. Which means there is absolutely no chance of a college football season this fall. Which means there is no college sports this fall or winter.
https://www.freep.com/story/sports/college/2020/08/10/big-ten-football-voted-cancel-fall-football-season/3334151001/
Woo Hoo!! Another thing to blame on Trump, right guys? [It's hard not to read some posts through that filter . . .].
"Woo hoo" like hell. This is a terrible loss for all and no sane person cheers it.
But blame Trump? Yes, damn right I do. I blame him with the vehemence that Jack Nicholson's character admitted to ordering the code red. Him and his enablers. Our performance as a nation is atrocious and — although there are other factors as well, of course — it's mainly because of leadership that purposely divided the nation during a crisis.
- In March he took to the airwaves to play it down, blame it on his detractors. Remember that? Unity in a crisis? Exactly the opposite.
- The mismanagement, the lies ... Kushner in charge of PPE and testing? National test and trace? Not a chance ... Trump just declares himself the best ever, but nothing happens. Except more and more division as he continues to ooze toxin from the bully pulpit. He's so bad that his cultists blame the press for reporting it, as if it's all imagined.
- April, May, June, continued attacks on political opponents, misinformation. The enormity of politicizing masks! He did that! Remember his "liberate" tweets promoting armed insurrection in two states. He made masks a political statement. Tulsa? The boondoggles like Kodak? Still no test and trace, no national plan, nothing but venom from our president.
- July, August, still no national plan, still no call for unity, more division, more venom from the top. Now it's all about blaming China. He pushes aside experts to take the podium himself, again, deciding to open schools, for example.
When does it end? New Zealand is down to no cases. Our covid deaths per capita in early August are fourth worse in the world, behind Mexico, Brazil, and South Africa. Our 22+ per million compare to 6 per million in the fifth worst country, UK; and less than 1 per million in Germany, France, etc.
Are we that incompetent as a nation? Hell no! We have a low-IQ corrupt malignant narcissist sewing hatred and division from the top.
RE: There will be no college football this season - teejers1 - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 03:26 PM)oregontim Wrote: ["Woo hoo" like hell. This is a terrible loss for all and no sane person cheers it.
But blame Trump? Yes, damn right I do . . .
There's a shocker!
A while back, a CNN (IIRC) anchor made a spot-on comment along lines of "Barack Obama is living rent free in your head" and directed it at Trump, who showed a bizarre obsession with his predecessor. I think that quip can be borrowed and applied to a handful of folks in these parts:
"President Trump is living rent-free in your head."
The antipathy is soooo strong that it colors your entire outlook . . . on everything.
But hey, that's just my Pop Psychology 101 take, and is worth about what you paid for it!
RE: There will be no college football this season - BostonCard - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 03:22 PM)teejers1 Wrote: Where I get off the train is that it is ALL Trump's fault or even an overwhelming majority. (But even giving him 50% of the blame should suffice for November purposes, imo, anyway). The track and trace efforts have been a joke; and there is no principled policy coming out of either Sacramento or Santa Clara County (which impacts my life more - indeed, state and county decisions impact the US population day-to-day far more than does federal action).
There is more than enough blame to go around (including some that can be directed to the Chinese Communist Party), not to mention state and local leaders. For example...
[tweet]https://twitter.com/ZackFinkNews/status/1292931659839528961?s=20p[/tweet]
Cuomo is not my governor, but I think it is ridiculous to hold him up as a paragon of COVID-19 response and a possible democratic candidate in the future. Newsom has had an up and down pandemic, but his decisive early leadership has evaporated.
BC
RE: There will be no college football this season - Goose - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 03:26 PM)oregontim Wrote: Are we that incompetent as a nation? Hell no! We have a low-IQ corrupt malignant narcissist sewing hatred and division from the top.Yes we are that incompetent as a nation. First of all, we elected the low-IQ corrupt malignant narcissist. He was clearly all those things from the day he first started running, and he won. However, I think there is much other evidence that we are collectively that incompetent. It was equally obvious in March, or at worst in April, that our State and Local governments had a lot on their plate. Generally, they too have failed, and not because of POTUS. The data FU in California can't be laid at Trump's door. Neither can the fact SCC appears to have no functioning track and trace. The non-compliance of so many in San Mateo County isn't Trump's fault. At this point, anybody who isn't a total idiot knows what is required of them, but many aren't doing it. Yep, we ARE the problem to a large extent.
RE: There will be no college football this season - oregontim - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 03:40 PM)teejers1 Wrote:(08-10-2020, 03:26 PM)oregontim Wrote: ["Woo hoo" like hell. This is a terrible loss for all and no sane person cheers it.
But blame Trump? Yes, damn right I do . . .
There's a shocker!
A while back, a CNN (IIRC) anchor made a spot-on comment along lines of "Barack Obama is living rent free in your head" and directed it at Trump, who showed a bizarre obsession with his predecessor. I think that quip can be borrowed and applied to a handful of folks in these parts:
"President Trump is living rent-free in your head."
The antipathy is soooo strong that it colors your entire outlook . . . on everything.
But hey, that's just my Pop Psychology 101 take, and is worth about what you paid for it!
OK, I can live with that. The antipathy is that strong. No argument. And yes to several of you who pointed out that 'we' as a nation voted him in (thanks, constitution, for the electoral college, that overvalues rural voters). And yes also to the sharing of the blame with some others ... even, Teejers, your thought ...
Quote:Where I get off the train is that it is ALL Trump's fault or even an overwhelming majority. (But even giving him 50% of the blame ...
... because I don't see myself assigning blame to all parties, like some would-be Solomon. For that matter, that's what Trump does, and I want no part of it.
And I can also see the growth of tribalism over several decades, the rise of the cult of celebrity, the disappearance of common ground and equal time and generalized truth as accepted facts, even the unavoidable perception of decline that was really industrial competition growing back after WWII, all of that contributing to the phenomenon that is Trump.
But I have more faith in this country than (apparently) most of you. I think the failures and local level are also attributable to some extent to the failure of leadership at the top. To cite just one partial example, if Trump had jumped over to masks in April or May, and turned things over to Fauci etc., Dems had already started in with masks, and the whole nation — both sides — would have adopted masks. Trump was the deciding factor that started everything else crumbling. IMO.
RE: There will be no college football this season - OutsiderFan - 08-10-2020
Getting this back on topic...
https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/29633697/heart-condition-linked-covid-19-fuels-power-5-concern-season-viability
At least 5 Big Ten athletes have been found to have Myocarditis and there are more from other conferences. Would be nice to know how many have been tested and how many have shown Myocarditis. But, if this is happening in athletes, what about the rest of the population who is getting infected?
RE: There will be no college football this season - M T - 08-10-2020
I wish much of the time spent blaming this or that were actually spent constructively finding ways to reduce the spread, help those that are sick or have already been sick, help those for whom this disruption has hit hard economically or educationally or psychologically, or ...
I appreciate those that are working their tail ends off toward the positive goals (whether they be medical workers, government statistics people, the critical workers, the people trying to do case tracing, or so many others). Unfortunately, there will be mistakes made and there will be those that will blame every misstep on someone or the other.
The vehemence I see on this board is discomforting. I've thought of dropping off because of the endless repetition of the same opinions we've seen for months. But, I can't monitor all areas, and some on this board do bring useful information that I might otherwise miss.
RE: There will be no college football this season - BostonCard - 08-10-2020
The Mountain West postponed all fall sports, including football.
https://themw.com/news/2020/8/10/general-mountain-west-postpones-2020-fall-sports.aspx
BC
RE: There will be no college football this season - dabigv13 - 08-10-2020
Cardboard readers should be ahead of the curve on the myocarditis talk, as its been a topic for a couple weeks now and I mentioned last week in this thread that it should give athletes pause.
Admins know that this is a risk now. If they proceed, and tens or hundreds of athletes get myocarditis, that's a pretty bad look...not to mention the concern about legal liability.
RE: There will be no college football this season - oregontim - 08-10-2020
(08-10-2020, 05:01 PM)M T Wrote: I wish much of the time spent blaming this or that were actually spent constructively finding ways to reduce the spread, help those that are sick or have already been sick, help those for whom this disruption has hit hard economically or educationally or psychologically, or ...
I appreciate those that are working their tail ends off toward the positive goals (whether they be medical workers, government statistics people, the critical workers, the people trying to do case tracing, or so many others). Unfortunately, there will be mistakes made and there will be those that will blame every misstep on someone or the other.
The vehemence I see on this board is discomforting. I've thought of dropping off because of the endless repetition of the same opinions we've seen for months. But, I can't monitor all areas, and some on this board do bring useful information that I might otherwise miss.
Points taken, M T. Apologies for both anger and repetition. Please don't drop off.