(06-16-2021, 01:47 PM)terry Wrote: (06-16-2021, 10:52 AM)ColoradoTree Wrote: And he's right that to do this midseason when guys haven't trained/prepared for it is unfair, and doing it this way will lead to more injuries as guys have to adjust how they grip the ball and pitch on the fly.
So, the players assumed they would be allowed to cheat, and now they're saying it's unfair that they need to figure out how to follow the rules?
I have a hard time summoning up much sympathy.
Again, I think banning spider tack or something similarly sticky is fair game at any point in any season. But there's a rosin bag at the mound, and rosin is an accepted means of improving a pitcher's grip on the ball. It is a standard tool of baseball, in other words. Sunscreen is necessary to protect against sunburn and skin cancer. That those two substances, both of which are acceptable for pitchers to use, at least individually, combine to form a mildly sticky substance that--and this is the key thing--improves grip but
does not improve spin rate doesn't amount to cheating, in my mind.
If I'm a pitcher and my sweaty sunscreened hands mix with the rosin that MLB has helpfully placed by the mound for me--where is the wrongful act? Where is the intentional flouting of the rules? You're allowed to use rosin, and you're allowed to use sunscreen to protect your skin.
Spider tack is something completely different--it's like super glue and
has been shown to dramatically improve spin rate. Ban that and punish players whenever you like. My concern is that something that does not strike me (or apparently most major league hitters) as cheating is now being banned, and it is forcing pitchers who are not the worst offenders to make changes midseason when their arms have not been trained for that. The prevailing view I've seen among major league hitters is that they are leery of pitchers throwing inside without some sort of grip aid--nobody wants to take a fastball to the head.
If you want to ban sunscreen/rosin moving forward, fine. Do it in the offseason and let guys build up their arms in such a way as they can maximize control and grip with whatever substances you deem acceptable. Then everyone is on the same page. Millions of dollars are at stake, along with guys' careers and reputations.
I agree that cheating is cheating, and you can reasonably punish it at any point during the season. I just quibble with sunscreen/rosin being considered cheating, or being deemed a foreign substance on par with spider tack or even pine tar. I just don't see it that way.
One thing that everyone--including MLB--seems to agree on is that balls come out of the box with sometimes significant variation on how slick they are. Hence the rosin bag, to allow pitchers to improve grip and make the ball a little easier to handle. That is the root of the problem, and MLB has given pitchers some level of leeway for years because they presumably agree that some minor corrective measures like that are appropriate. But as with anything in life, you give an inch, and someone takes a mile, and you have a minority of pitchers going to extremes. Yes, police the extremes, but a policy shift like this is better done after studied consideration with time for players to adjust, not this sort of ad hoc line in the sand midseason.
(FWIW, I never cared about the amount of pine tar on George Brett's bat, while the emery board and sandpaper Joe Niekro used to doctor balls in 1987 was messed up. He got a 10-day suspension for getting caught with an emery board and sandpaper on the mound. But that 10-game suspension is what everyone with any sort of substance beyond pure rosin will get. I just don't see those things as equally culpable.)