[pauloalto]

McCaffrey is 1st team as a RB on 2 lists, 1st team returner/all-purpose on 2 lists, and 2nd team for both on 1 list.  So, if I understand it correctly, McCaffrey is not a consensus all-american.  Absurd.

He is tied with Evan Berry of Tennessee as a consensus All-American all purpose/kick return player. They each have 2 first team listings and one second team for that position. You don't need 3 first place honors at a position to be consensus, you need to have the most and at least 2.

[pauloalto]

McCaffrey is 1st team as a RB on 2 lists, 1st team returner/all-purpose on 2 lists, and 2nd team for both on 1 list.  So, if I understand it correctly, McCaffrey is not a consensus all-american.  Absurd.

He is tied with Evan Berry of Tennessee as a consensus All-American all purpose/kick return player. They each have 2 first team listings and one second team for that position. You don't need 3 first place honors at a position to be consensus, you need to have the most and at least 2.