[AthleticsDynasty]

...Even Bama isn't winning with a bunch or freshman and sophomores. Thats not realistic and never has been. Also forget 5 years we can't even keep them for 4 years

fwiw, Alabama has 8 FR or SO in the offensive 2-deep, including 3 SO starters.  on defense, Alabama has 11 FR or SO in the 2-deep including 5 FR/SO starters.  Alabama plays (and develops) young talent rather than deferring to seniority.  I wish Shaw would do more of that (or both).

How many of those sophomores are RS sophomores? Either way a majority of the players are uppclassmen,  winning with freshman and  sophomores is not realistic even at Bama where they can take 25+ recuiting classed every year and cut players on whim.

[AthleticsDynasty]

...Even Bama isn't winning with a bunch or freshman and sophomores. Thats not realistic and never has been. Also forget 5 years we can't even keep them for 4 years

fwiw, Alabama has 8 FR or SO in the offensive 2-deep, including 3 SO starters.  on defense, Alabama has 11 FR or SO in the 2-deep including 5 FR/SO starters.  Alabama plays (and develops) young talent rather than deferring to seniority.  I wish Shaw would do more of that (or both).

How many of those sophomores are RS sophomores? Either way a majority of the players are uppclassmen,  winning with freshman and  sophomores is not realistic even at Bama where they can take 25+ recuiting classed every year and cut players on whim.