[Mick]

Santiago.

Haller

Molina

Yadier Molina won nine GGs.  Bengie Molina won two, both with the Angels pre-SF Giants.  Haller never won it, and his best years actually came with the Dodgers.  Santiago won three Gold Gloves, all with the Padres pre-SF Giants.

The Giants' catchers who won a Gold Glove include Posey (2016); Mike Matheny who won three in a row, the first two with the Cardinals, the last with the Giants in 2005; and Kirt Manwaring (1993).  Manwaring was an excellent defensive catcher.  He threw out 42% (or more) of stolen base attempts in five seasons, leading the league twice in 1992 (51%) and 1993 (46%).  By comparison, Buster's best season was 38%.

[Mick]

Santiago.

Haller

Molina

Yadier Molina won nine GGs.  Bengie Molina won two, both with the Angels pre-SF Giants.  Haller never won it, and his best years actually came with the Dodgers.  Santiago won three Gold Gloves, all with the Padres pre-SF Giants.

The Giants' catchers who won a Gold Glove include Posey (2016); Mike Matheny who won three in a row, the first two with the Cardinals, the last with the Giants in 2005; and Kirt Manwaring (1993).  Manwaring was an excellent defensive catcher.  He threw out 42% (or more) of stolen base attempts in five seasons, leading the league twice in 1992 (51%) and 1993 (46%).  By comparison, Buster's best season was 38%.