[DC 86]

 Are you arguing that drunk drivers shouldn't be detained, out of compassion for the issues that may have precipitated their drinking?

Isn't that bit somewhat a straw man? 

They accomplished that without injuring RS 

Well, except for the bite from the dog, no?

Police not being called into this incident was the actual argument, so I don't consider it a straw man. I suppose social workers can conduct citizen's arrests but that wasn't suggested, and seems impractical when dealing with a volatile individual.

I stand corrected, he did sustain a minor dog bite.

[DC 86]

 Are you arguing that drunk drivers shouldn't be detained, out of compassion for the issues that may have precipitated their drinking?

Isn't that bit somewhat a straw man? 

They accomplished that without injuring RS 

Well, except for the bite from the dog, no?

Police not being called into this incident was the actual argument, so I don't consider it a straw man. I suppose social workers can conduct citizen's arrests but that wasn't suggested, and seems impractical when dealing with a volatile individual.

I stand corrected, he did sustain a minor dog bite.