[OutsiderFan]

Finally, though I didn't think the roughing the last passer call was legit, it was still a product of undisciplined play.

If you mean the call on the tying TD drive, it was cut and dried. Any contact to the neck or head of a QB while throwing is roughing the passer. It doesn't have to be late.

It may be a penalty by the letter of the law, but when I saw the replay no part of me thought it was worth a penalty.  The tackle on Tremayne was far, far more penalty-worthy IMO. And I didn't think the hold on #63 that wiped out a big gain was worth a penalty either,  so I'm not playing favorites here. Penalties should be called when they are flagrant violations of the rules or create an unfair advantage on a given play.

And I almost forgot the blindside hit Oregon's Redd laid on on Gilman.  That was another dirty play I forgot to point out in the initial thread.

[OutsiderFan]

Finally, though I didn't think the roughing the last passer call was legit, it was still a product of undisciplined play.

If you mean the call on the tying TD drive, it was cut and dried. Any contact to the neck or head of a QB while throwing is roughing the passer. It doesn't have to be late.

It may be a penalty by the letter of the law, but when I saw the replay no part of me thought it was worth a penalty.  The tackle on Tremayne was far, far more penalty-worthy IMO. And I didn't think the hold on #63 that wiped out a big gain was worth a penalty either,  so I'm not playing favorites here. Penalties should be called when they are flagrant violations of the rules or create an unfair advantage on a given play.

And I almost forgot the blindside hit Oregon's Redd laid on on Gilman.  That was another dirty play I forgot to point out in the initial thread.