[Ratmandoo]

[quote author=garvin link=topic=6545.msg48743#msg48743 date=1348946777]
You pick a quarterback. If he doesn't do the job, you replace him.

Are you happy with the way this is working out this year?

You don't see the fundamental approach to be not as strong when you don't have an One Who Now Plays for the Colts is on the roster? 
[/quote]

So let's say Nunes and Nottingham both had two quarters to play in the first game and neither separated themselves from each other. Do you do that again for the second game? And then the third game? It's just too difficult to keep switching back and forth between quarterbacks for one to really play well. Just ask Texas - the David Ash-Case McCoy QB switch last year was terrible. Now that they settled on David Ash this year, they have found out that he can play. Or ask Florida with Jeff Driskel and Jacoby Brissett - last year was a mess rotating between these two but now Driskell has developed into a competent quarterback now that he doesn't have to look over his shoulder.

I agree with Garvin....make the choice and let him play until he proves it isn't working.

[Ratmandoo]

[quote author=garvin link=topic=6545.msg48743#msg48743 date=1348946777]
You pick a quarterback. If he doesn't do the job, you replace him.

Are you happy with the way this is working out this year?

You don't see the fundamental approach to be not as strong when you don't have an One Who Now Plays for the Colts is on the roster? 
[/quote]

So let's say Nunes and Nottingham both had two quarters to play in the first game and neither separated themselves from each other. Do you do that again for the second game? And then the third game? It's just too difficult to keep switching back and forth between quarterbacks for one to really play well. Just ask Texas - the David Ash-Case McCoy QB switch last year was terrible. Now that they settled on David Ash this year, they have found out that he can play. Or ask Florida with Jeff Driskel and Jacoby Brissett - last year was a mess rotating between these two but now Driskell has developed into a competent quarterback now that he doesn't have to look over his shoulder.

I agree with Garvin....make the choice and let him play until he proves it isn't working.