[washingtonismoney]

I don't think Ash separated himself at all.

QB A, 2011: 57% completion, 6.2 YPA, 4 TD 8 INT
QB B, 2011: 61.1% completion, 7.18 YPA, 7 TD 4 INT.

I know which one I'd much rather have, if all we're judging on is on-field performance.

QB B, Case McCoy. I think we'd be going crazy--and justifiably so--if Shaw picked QB A and insisted QB A was better with some coachspeak that is somehow uniquely infuriating to Shaw detractors.

I'm also struggling to see how your question is responsive to Ratmandoo.

[washingtonismoney]

I don't think Ash separated himself at all.

QB A, 2011: 57% completion, 6.2 YPA, 4 TD 8 INT
QB B, 2011: 61.1% completion, 7.18 YPA, 7 TD 4 INT.

I know which one I'd much rather have, if all we're judging on is on-field performance.

QB B, Case McCoy. I think we'd be going crazy--and justifiably so--if Shaw picked QB A and insisted QB A was better with some coachspeak that is somehow uniquely infuriating to Shaw detractors.

I'm also struggling to see how your question is responsive to Ratmandoo.