[SamuelMcF]

Wondering how our recruits stack up against some other Pac-12's.

                  5-star  4-star  3-star  Total
Stanford          1        2        7      10
CAL                 0        2        8      10
ASU                 0        4        5        9
Colorado          0        4        5        9
Wash St           0        4        5        9
Utah                0        1        7        8

Note Maxime Raynaud & Michael Jones don't show up in the Stanford count,
because both are (underrated) as 2 stars on the sheets I checked.
If a school had a transfer and I found a Transfer rating for them, I used that instead of their HS rating.
I think there's no way you could argue that we are undermanned against these teams.
Yet we went 0-5 against them so far.

Using the "transfer rating" instead of HS doesn't translate. There are just 25 4* transfers (per 247) and 130ish 4*+ HS recruits in each class. It's not the same scale. HS ratings at least keep it level.

Utah thus has 2 more 4*s (HS), ASU has another 4* (HS), Cal has another 4* (HS), and Wazzu has another 4* (HS, by 247).

We don't "out-talent" basically anyone, especially with one of our 4*s currently being redshirted. It's Harrison Ingram, Isa Silva (who doesn't even start), and an army of 3*s.

[To be clear, I also believe the team is very poorly coached. That's abundantly clear. I just don't think we actually "have the talent" people continue to think we do.]

[SamuelMcF]

Wondering how our recruits stack up against some other Pac-12's.

                  5-star  4-star  3-star  Total
Stanford          1        2        7      10
CAL                 0        2        8      10
ASU                 0        4        5        9
Colorado          0        4        5        9
Wash St           0        4        5        9
Utah                0        1        7        8

Note Maxime Raynaud & Michael Jones don't show up in the Stanford count,
because both are (underrated) as 2 stars on the sheets I checked.
If a school had a transfer and I found a Transfer rating for them, I used that instead of their HS rating.
I think there's no way you could argue that we are undermanned against these teams.
Yet we went 0-5 against them so far.

Using the "transfer rating" instead of HS doesn't translate. There are just 25 4* transfers (per 247) and 130ish 4*+ HS recruits in each class. It's not the same scale. HS ratings at least keep it level.

Utah thus has 2 more 4*s (HS), ASU has another 4* (HS), Cal has another 4* (HS), and Wazzu has another 4* (HS, by 247).

We don't "out-talent" basically anyone, especially with one of our 4*s currently being redshirted. It's Harrison Ingram, Isa Silva (who doesn't even start), and an army of 3*s.

[To be clear, I also believe the team is very poorly coached. That's abundantly clear. I just don't think we actually "have the talent" people continue to think we do.]