[terry]

Canceso and McGuire
Bonds and Kent
Aaron and Mathews 1st
Ruth and Gerhig

Aaron and Mathews are correct. Bonus points for correctly guessing that they are #1 on the list. They hit 863 home runs in 1954-1966.

Ruth and Gehrig are correct, with 859 home runs in 1923-1934. They rank 2nd on the list.

Not Bonds and Kent (454 HRs in 1997-2002).

Not Canseco and McGwire (400+ HRs in 1986-1991 and parts of 1992 and 1997. I haven't gone back to count exactly how many HRs each of them hit during the partial seasons they were teammates).

Are Billy Williams and Ernie Banks on that list? Mantle & Berra? Mays & McCovey?

Mays and McCovey are correct, with 801 HRs in 1959-71 and part of 1972. They rank 3rd on the list.

Not Banks and Williams (648 HRs in 1959-71).

Not Mantle and Berra (702 HRs in 1951-63).

[terry]

Canceso and McGuire
Bonds and Kent
Aaron and Mathews 1st
Ruth and Gerhig

Aaron and Mathews are correct. Bonus points for correctly guessing that they are #1 on the list. They hit 863 home runs in 1954-1966.

Ruth and Gehrig are correct, with 859 home runs in 1923-1934. They rank 2nd on the list.

Not Bonds and Kent (454 HRs in 1997-2002).

Not Canseco and McGwire (400+ HRs in 1986-1991 and parts of 1992 and 1997. I haven't gone back to count exactly how many HRs each of them hit during the partial seasons they were teammates).

Are Billy Williams and Ernie Banks on that list? Mantle & Berra? Mays & McCovey?

Mays and McCovey are correct, with 801 HRs in 1959-71 and part of 1972. They rank 3rd on the list.

Not Banks and Williams (648 HRs in 1959-71).

Not Mantle and Berra (702 HRs in 1951-63).