[terry]

Tommy John is not in the HOF, but there's a good case for including him. If Jim Kaat is in the Hall, why not Tommy John?

.................Tommy John...Jim Kaat
W/L..............288-231......283-237
ERA................3.34...........3.45
WAR...............61.6..........50.5
WHIP..............1.28..........1.26

Of course, it may not a good idea to pick one of the weakest HOF members and set that as the bar. That arguably could open the doors too much....

[terry]

Tommy John is not in the HOF, but there's a good case for including him. If Jim Kaat is in the Hall, why not Tommy John?

.................Tommy John...Jim Kaat
W/L..............288-231......283-237
ERA................3.34...........3.45
WAR...............61.6..........50.5
WHIP..............1.28..........1.26

Of course, it may not a good idea to pick one of the weakest HOF members and set that as the bar. That arguably could open the doors too much....