[Leftcoast]

Or John Smoltz.  He must have been a Cy Young contender in his 4 years in the Atlanta bullpen and he won one in '96 as a starter.

---

Final guess - Former Giant tormenter and Dodger closer Eric Gagne, who played in the same timeframe as John Smoltz. Tough to win the NL West back when both the Dodgers and the Braves were peaking.

[Leftcoast]

Or John Smoltz.  He must have been a Cy Young contender in his 4 years in the Atlanta bullpen and he won one in '96 as a starter.

---

Final guess - Former Giant tormenter and Dodger closer Eric Gagne, who played in the same timeframe as John Smoltz. Tough to win the NL West back when both the Dodgers and the Braves were peaking.