[KartyFan]

I'm all for critiquing coaches, that's part of what makes being a fan fun. But the idea that we might know better than the coaches which QB should play when they have dozens of practices and we have essentially nothing is, in my opinion, crazy. They do this for a living, AND they have so much more information than we do. In fact, the only data we have on Brown is from last year, when he was really bad.

Is it possible the coaches are making the wrong decisions on QB? Sure. But we have no idea, so I'm not going to get worked up about it and judge the coaching staff on this. If I'm going to second guess, I will at least do it on in-game decisions where we have pretty full information.

We will never know, but there's a great chance that we would be 0-4 if we had made the QB change many were asking for after BYU.

[KartyFan]

I'm all for critiquing coaches, that's part of what makes being a fan fun. But the idea that we might know better than the coaches which QB should play when they have dozens of practices and we have essentially nothing is, in my opinion, crazy. They do this for a living, AND they have so much more information than we do. In fact, the only data we have on Brown is from last year, when he was really bad.

Is it possible the coaches are making the wrong decisions on QB? Sure. But we have no idea, so I'm not going to get worked up about it and judge the coaching staff on this. If I'm going to second guess, I will at least do it on in-game decisions where we have pretty full information.

We will never know, but there's a great chance that we would be 0-4 if we had made the QB change many were asking for after BYU.