If this were a four-team playoff year, everyone (neutral fans) would be happy and looking forward to seeing undefeated Indiana and one-loss Ohio State, Texas Tech and Georgia all play.
Biggest gripers would be Ole Miss at 11-1, but with a head-to-head loss to Georgia (by eight points); Oregon at 11-1, but with a loss to Indiana that would be objectively worse (at home, by two scores) compared to Ohio State's loss to Indiana, and Texas A&M at 11-1, but they would have a multi-score loss as their last game of the season.
Texas Tech's lone loss would have come on the road by four points while playing its back-up QB the entire game because of injury. We also would be hearing a lot about the (made up) importance of a team winning its conference championship, and most of us would have nodded along simply because having TT in a four-team playoff is objectively more fun than having two SEC teams and two B1Gs or three B1Gs and one SEC team.
The system would have worked!
Biggest gripers would be Ole Miss at 11-1, but with a head-to-head loss to Georgia (by eight points); Oregon at 11-1, but with a loss to Indiana that would be objectively worse (at home, by two scores) compared to Ohio State's loss to Indiana, and Texas A&M at 11-1, but they would have a multi-score loss as their last game of the season.
Texas Tech's lone loss would have come on the road by four points while playing its back-up QB the entire game because of injury. We also would be hearing a lot about the (made up) importance of a team winning its conference championship, and most of us would have nodded along simply because having TT in a four-team playoff is objectively more fun than having two SEC teams and two B1Gs or three B1Gs and one SEC team.
The system would have worked!
