[slide]

garvin has done a good job pointing out the flaws in each.  I'll just note that I didn't make those up.  They were summaries of the comments that have surfaced over Shaw's two seasons.  Valid or not,  they're a fair  summary the dominant views of Shaw turning up in media and fan comments. 

I think there was some uncertainty about how much of the offense went through Shaw under Harbaugh.  Roman and Taggart among others also had a big say in the offense's construction. 

I hope it works out well for Shaw.  winning the Pac-12 this year frankly was a shock to me given the QB and OL question marks starting (and remaining through much of) the year.  and recruiting wise, Shaw has definitely put his own mark on how he will recruit at Stanford, building on the positives from Harbaugh's (and even Buddy's) time.  the biggest change is how many scholarships he offers.  looking at the '14 class, we are definitely competing for more nationally ranked players (Peppers, Chryst, Hand etc) than I can recall

[slide]

garvin has done a good job pointing out the flaws in each.  I'll just note that I didn't make those up.  They were summaries of the comments that have surfaced over Shaw's two seasons.  Valid or not,  they're a fair  summary the dominant views of Shaw turning up in media and fan comments. 

I think there was some uncertainty about how much of the offense went through Shaw under Harbaugh.  Roman and Taggart among others also had a big say in the offense's construction. 

I hope it works out well for Shaw.  winning the Pac-12 this year frankly was a shock to me given the QB and OL question marks starting (and remaining through much of) the year.  and recruiting wise, Shaw has definitely put his own mark on how he will recruit at Stanford, building on the positives from Harbaugh's (and even Buddy's) time.  the biggest change is how many scholarships he offers.  looking at the '14 class, we are definitely competing for more nationally ranked players (Peppers, Chryst, Hand etc) than I can recall