Posts: 30,062
Threads: 2,135
Joined: Dec 2013
I think there are a few separate things going on. The first is the effect of the transfer portal on women’s basketball generally, which I think has been bad for the sport. I think it sucks that teams like Iowa State and Tennessee have to rebuild essentially from scratch, and will have a de novo roster. As a fan, you are left with either taking the jacketree approach (forget the name in front of the jersey and just root for the team, regardless of who is playing for it), or lose interest.
If that were the only issue, I think that would generally be a bad thing for Stanford for the reason that recruiting inbound transfers is just going to be harder at Stanford, even if you make significant compromises on what admissions is willing to do, which has already happened (see, for example, the post-bac graduate program and a willingness to expedite evaluations of transfers). I don’t think it is a coincidence that Stanford is struggling in all the high profile sports (football, mens and women’s basketball, baseball) at the same time, and this is even affecting some non-high profile sports (Cannady transferring out of the softball team, the struggles this year with tennis, hell, the wrestling team is dealing with a deluge of outbound transfers right after its best season ever and has noted that other teams have a substantially larger budget), and we’ve seen transfers out of both the men’s and women’s swimming teams.
On top of that, there seems to be some specific allegations against Coach Paye or the rest of the coaching staff. At this point, I don’t think any of us are in a position to adjudicate whether they are true or not, but I did note that a couple of the portal announcements were decidedly cold towards the staff; “I have informed the coaches of my intention to transfer” (I think was the way Amborn phrased it), without even a perfunctory thanks or polite generic statement about the staff if for no other reason than to ensure you don’t burn bridges on your way out. Maybe it is all disgruntled and/or entitled players, but I think there is enough cause for suspicion that someone in the athletics department needs to investigate the allegations and determine whether a) they are true and b) whether they go so far as to be a fireable offense.
We may have a limited ability to influence the external environment (certainly would qualify as a threat in the SWOT diagram), but we certainly owe it to our players to foster a positive internal environment and do everything we can make sure that we aren’t exacerbating the situation.
BC