Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - Printable Version
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart (/thread-14115.html)
+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart (/thread-14115.html)
Pages:
1
2
Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - AncientCityIndian - 08-24-2017
Outside of necessary injury replacements, I find it difficult to believe Alfieri is listed as a backup at ILB and Jay Tyler at 5'7" tall is listed ahead of the 6'4' Donald Stewart at one WR. We will see how it plays out, I guess.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - JohnR34231 - 08-24-2017
My guess:
1. Alfieri is new to the position, so the coaches felt that he had to clearly demonstrate in game conditions that he deserves to be the top guy.
2. Tyler is our best "speed" receiver and Shaw felt the need to have a guy like that in the two deep.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - Durty Nelly - 08-24-2017
Where is the depth chart available?
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - lex24 - 08-24-2017
Alfieri, to my eyes, was their best linebacker last year. So whether he starts are not, he should be on the field a lot. If not, he should not have been moved.
Stewart not getting ahead of Tyler is disappointing to me.
Has he been hurt?? At 5'8 Tyler is more suited to the slot. Hopefully he will line up there at times.
Interesting to see how many snaps Weddington gets.
Any word on JJ, Mike Tyler and Hall. 3 starters out for opener. Not good.
On a positive note- has Stanford ever been this deep in the defensive backfield. All second teamers are experienced, athletic and talented.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - Mick - 08-24-2017
(08-24-2017, 07:32 AM)AncientCityIndian link Wrote:Outside of necessary injury replacements, I find it difficult to believe Alfieri is listed as a backup at ILB and Jay Tyler at 5'7" tall is listed ahead of the 6'4' Donald Stewart at one WR. We will see how it plays out, I guess.
How tall was Troy Walters?
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - Phogge - 08-24-2017
Ancient Indian, I'm hoping that the old cliche about the size of the fight in the man means that Tyler is The Man at his position. There are some very tough small players who have come out of St. Augustine.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - AncientCityIndian - 08-24-2017
They are still pretty tough, albeit a bit slow and overweight. Our starting center, Burkett, however, is neither slow or overweight and is a tough local boy.
I really liked the Jay Tyler recruitment given that he played QB and was all everything at his HS in Louisiana. I thought he might play early as a 3rd down guy or returner but with Mac and Love, it was not to be. Since he did not make any impact his first few years, I then felt he might end up being a dud. If my initial impressions were more accurate than my revised ones, I will be pretty happy. I understand that at WR there is quite a rotation during the game and 3 or 4 guys play substantially but Stewart apparently impressed enough last year to have his true frosh redshirt burned which is unusual for a wideout. To see him replaced by Tyler at this point was a true surprise to me, but I will be ecstatic if it works out to our great advantage.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - BobK - 08-24-2017
Stewart will be fine just a minor injury kept him out of some practices.  Thus he is 2 on the depth chart.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - OutsiderFan - 08-24-2017
No JJAW on the depth chart is shocking. Did Weddington beat him out?
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - AncientCityIndian - 08-24-2017
A_W is hurt.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - JohnR34231 - 08-24-2017
(08-24-2017, 10:02 AM)AncientCityIndian link Wrote:A_W is hurt.
Any idea how seriously (in other words will he be back for U$C)?
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - CTcard - 08-24-2017
(08-24-2017, 07:56 AM)Durty Nelly link Wrote:Where is the depth chart available?
http://www.gostanford.com/documents/2017/8/24/fb_rice_depth.pdf
It would be helpful if we could combine the two threads on the depth chart.
(08-24-2017, 07:32 AM)AncientCityIndian link Wrote:... I find it difficult to believe Alfieri is listed as a backup at ILB and Jay Tyler at 5'7" tall is listed ahead of the 6'4' Donald Stewart at one WR. We will see how it plays out, I guess.
I suspect (along with JPRI) that Alfieri's position on the depth chart is pro forma.
He may not start, but I suspect he will see as many snaps as any linebacker.
The WR depth chart is ... sobering. All the WR on the depth chart not named Irwin, combined, have two career catches.
I suspect that we will see Parkinson, and possibly Smith, used primarily as a WR or large slot receiver. Sure hope Wedington is a revelation.
Frosh on the depth chart = Parkinson, Sarrell, Little, Wedington.
Presumably at least these four will not redshirt.
I had come to expect Simmons over Buncom at safety but it's notable to see it.
I am also surprised by the disappearance of Perez.
And I'll be watching to see who is the most common nickel back.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - AncientCityIndian - 08-24-2017
I record every game since I only get to see a few games a year. I watch replays with the DVR pretty often. Every so often, I will focus on just one position group for a game replay and game by game comparison. 9 months of replays, especially now that I am fully retired. With all due respect, if you watched a lot of tape of Perez last year, you would answer your own question.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - fullmetal - 08-24-2017
AncientCity, you are my hero.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - Phogge - 08-24-2017
Ancient has been my hero for a decade. A true to life Mickey Rooney character with a bit of Eddie Arcaro thrown in. He could probably purchase half of Stanford's real estate if he so desired.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - JohnR34231 - 08-24-2017
(08-24-2017, 12:08 PM)Phogge link Wrote:Ancient has been my hero for a decade. A true to life Mickey Rooney character with a bit of Eddie Arcaro thrown in. He could probably purchase half of Stanford's real estate if he so desired.
Whoa, maybe we should be asking for investing tips rather than tips on Stanford football.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - CTcard - 08-24-2017
(08-24-2017, 10:16 AM)AncientCityIndian link Wrote:I record every game since I only get to see a few games a year. I watch replays with the DVR pretty often. Every so often, I will focus on just one position group for a game replay and game by game comparison. 9 months of replays, especially now that I am fully retired. With all due respect, if you watched a lot of tape of Perez last year, you would answer your own question.
I didn't pose a question wrt Perez, but took note he was off the depth chart.
The surprise I expressed was more of a coaches' perception/attitude thing - it's rare that you see upper classmen disappear like that.
I also watch a lot of Stanford tape. I would take the intermediate view that while Perez clearly struggled at times, he wasn't a unique problem to the degree that this board appeared to believe.
One of the great things about the cloud, is that it is mostly no longer necessary to record most games in order to rewatch. Unfortunately, the Pac-12 network has gone squirrelly about making past games available. It used to be that every game the Pac 12 had the rights to became available about a month after the original broadcast, now I see only six available from 2016: Rice, Arizona, Colorado, WSU, UCLA, Kansas St. Youtube has about 8 or 9 games from last season available to anyone, including all of those missing from the list above.
Lately, I have been rewatching the Rice game, preparing to crush the prediction game round 1.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - Langdude - 08-24-2017
Regarding Alfieri's switch to ILB, I think it is telling that Kevin Palma, who began as a starter last year, is now a backup; we are looking for more speed and coverage ability it seems. However, it is surprising that Mustafa Branch, the only freshman LB not to redshirt two years ago, is still not a starter...
-m.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - donkey687 - 08-24-2017
(08-24-2017, 01:31 PM)Langdude link Wrote:Regarding Alfieri's switch to ILB, I think it is telling that Kevin Palma, who began as a starter last year, is now a backup; we are looking for more speed and coverage ability it seems. However, it is surprising that Mustafa Branch, the only freshman LB not to redshirt two years ago, is still not a starter...Branch has shined since his frosh year on special teams kickoff coverage, and I think that is the reason he played as a frosh. His type of play may be better suited to that open kickoff environment than the structure required of playing ILB.
-m.
Re: Two Big Surprises For Me With Initial Depth Chart - needle - 08-24-2017
Last year, being a "starting" ILB didn't actually mean you played the majority of snaps. I would hesitate to read too much into the depth chart, and I would assume Perez is not listed because he's hurt (similar to JJAW).