[yvonne]

Baylor was 1-3 in away games the year RGIII won it. Luck had only the loss to Oregon at the time of the vote.

Wins mattered when Newton won it, but not the next year.

What's more, the voters used the better team logic to deny Toby the Voldemort when he had the better stats. In other words, they used one set of logic to vote against Toby, and then threw it out the window in order to deny Luck.

[yvonne]

Baylor was 1-3 in away games the year RGIII won it. Luck had only the loss to Oregon at the time of the vote.

Wins mattered when Newton won it, but not the next year.

What's more, the voters used the better team logic to deny Toby the Voldemort when he had the better stats. In other words, they used one set of logic to vote against Toby, and then threw it out the window in order to deny Luck.