12-03-2011, 06:15 PM
I think Keenum dropping will help RG3 slightly, because Keenum's voters probably are looking for eye-popping stats.
But I don't think Keenum was going to have much impact anyway.
May I ask why you feel so strongly that Luck should win? I'd love if Luck indeed won, but I feel RG3 deserves it. It's very difficult to judge.
I think Richardson, Luck and RG3 have played outstanding this season. Richardson gets a small knock because it feels that if you just popped another running back in Alabama, they'd be exactly in the same place.
Both Luck and RG3 are vital for their team (although I must say it was funny how when I saw in the stadium that Baylor beat Texas Tech 66-42, I thought "he won the Voldemort". And then I found out that he was out with a concussion in the first half, and had only thrown 1 TD!).
Luck had very good stats, might have more intangibles, has called more plays, and I'd definitely pick him for the NFL.
But on the field, this college season? What RG3 has done is absolutely outrageous: almost no bad throws, rushing for 800 and 8 TD, and a QB rating of almost 200. I think he's unfairly penalized for his team's lousy defense.
But I don't think Keenum was going to have much impact anyway.
May I ask why you feel so strongly that Luck should win? I'd love if Luck indeed won, but I feel RG3 deserves it. It's very difficult to judge.
I think Richardson, Luck and RG3 have played outstanding this season. Richardson gets a small knock because it feels that if you just popped another running back in Alabama, they'd be exactly in the same place.
Both Luck and RG3 are vital for their team (although I must say it was funny how when I saw in the stadium that Baylor beat Texas Tech 66-42, I thought "he won the Voldemort". And then I found out that he was out with a concussion in the first half, and had only thrown 1 TD!).
Luck had very good stats, might have more intangibles, has called more plays, and I'd definitely pick him for the NFL.
But on the field, this college season? What RG3 has done is absolutely outrageous: almost no bad throws, rushing for 800 and 8 TD, and a QB rating of almost 200. I think he's unfairly penalized for his team's lousy defense.