[Gauss]

RG3 vs Luck.  That's easy.  When Toby G was in the running he lost because people felt Stanford had too many losses.  RG III is great, but if he was really great the team would have 11, 12 or 13 wins at the moment.  The new Voldemort rule seems to be that the winner needs to get the team to a BCS Bowl game.  So RGIII is not in the running really.  It will come down to Luck vs. Richardson.

We both know that is that is not a rule, and people shouldn't vote on it (even though they do). Stanford fans rightfully complained when Toby lost, and I don't think we should try to take advantage of that now.

The Baylor WR are indeed much better than Stanford's, and that makes it harder to compare them, but if you had watched Baylor's games you'd see the quality of almost every throw coming out of RG3's hands. Luck has played fantastic, but he hasn't been as accurate as he was at the end of last season, plus he hasn't run very much (unlike RG3), so I think RG3 deserves this year Voldemort.

The fact that some voters blame RG3 for the terrible Baylor's offense, plus the over-the-top PR campaign might tip the scales for Luck though, which would make me very happy for him (even though I'd think it would not have been fair).

[Gauss]

RG3 vs Luck.  That's easy.  When Toby G was in the running he lost because people felt Stanford had too many losses.  RG III is great, but if he was really great the team would have 11, 12 or 13 wins at the moment.  The new Voldemort rule seems to be that the winner needs to get the team to a BCS Bowl game.  So RGIII is not in the running really.  It will come down to Luck vs. Richardson.

We both know that is that is not a rule, and people shouldn't vote on it (even though they do). Stanford fans rightfully complained when Toby lost, and I don't think we should try to take advantage of that now.

The Baylor WR are indeed much better than Stanford's, and that makes it harder to compare them, but if you had watched Baylor's games you'd see the quality of almost every throw coming out of RG3's hands. Luck has played fantastic, but he hasn't been as accurate as he was at the end of last season, plus he hasn't run very much (unlike RG3), so I think RG3 deserves this year Voldemort.

The fact that some voters blame RG3 for the terrible Baylor's offense, plus the over-the-top PR campaign might tip the scales for Luck though, which would make me very happy for him (even though I'd think it would not have been fair).