09-21-2017, 05:39 AM
1: David Shaw for all his talents is not an O genius.
2: Tavita Pritchard brings little to the table as a QB coach.
3: Since Harbaugh left, we have not developed a QB and have done a reasonably poor job of QB recruiting evaluation. Hogan had his great days but his performance was at times uneven and he was recruited by Harbaugh.
4: Because of our QB selection and development, we have had an inconsistent O despite great players at most other positions.
5: The O is WAY too complicated and too difficult to implement, hampering instinctive ability and talent.
Conclusion: We need a dedicated OC and a dedicated QB coach with the talent to recruit the right guy. We need a Duane Akina for our QB position.
Shaw`s stubbornness and blindness to his own inadequacy as an O coordinator has risen to the point that out program is regressing since the Pac 12 has been upgraded by the resurrection of Utah, Oregon, Washington, Washington State and USC; moreover, his O will never evolve because he refuses to hire anyone with the talent or substance and personality to challenge his dominance. Shaw will hire strong D assistants but not on O. His O assistants are all sycophantic to a degree. Does anyone really think Tavita will question a Shaw decision or push him to change? We need someone to challenge Shaw on O. We need a Lincoln Riley type to be able to tell Shaw to take a back seat and run the overall program which he does superbly and let the O coordinator run the O show.
Josh Rosen WOULD have been better than anyone we have on the roster at QB despite his personality and our poor inadequate QB development.
IF we win Saturday against UCLA, we will need 35+ points against a very poor defense. I`m not even sure we can achieve that. We might be looking at a 5-7 or 4-8 season this year. Maybe that is what it will take to wake Shaw up and overcome his superego because we will never come close to winning 10 games again given the upgraded competition without Shaw upgrading the O coaching staff to the level of the D staff.
2: Tavita Pritchard brings little to the table as a QB coach.
3: Since Harbaugh left, we have not developed a QB and have done a reasonably poor job of QB recruiting evaluation. Hogan had his great days but his performance was at times uneven and he was recruited by Harbaugh.
4: Because of our QB selection and development, we have had an inconsistent O despite great players at most other positions.
5: The O is WAY too complicated and too difficult to implement, hampering instinctive ability and talent.
Conclusion: We need a dedicated OC and a dedicated QB coach with the talent to recruit the right guy. We need a Duane Akina for our QB position.
Shaw`s stubbornness and blindness to his own inadequacy as an O coordinator has risen to the point that out program is regressing since the Pac 12 has been upgraded by the resurrection of Utah, Oregon, Washington, Washington State and USC; moreover, his O will never evolve because he refuses to hire anyone with the talent or substance and personality to challenge his dominance. Shaw will hire strong D assistants but not on O. His O assistants are all sycophantic to a degree. Does anyone really think Tavita will question a Shaw decision or push him to change? We need someone to challenge Shaw on O. We need a Lincoln Riley type to be able to tell Shaw to take a back seat and run the overall program which he does superbly and let the O coordinator run the O show.
Josh Rosen WOULD have been better than anyone we have on the roster at QB despite his personality and our poor inadequate QB development.
IF we win Saturday against UCLA, we will need 35+ points against a very poor defense. I`m not even sure we can achieve that. We might be looking at a 5-7 or 4-8 season this year. Maybe that is what it will take to wake Shaw up and overcome his superego because we will never come close to winning 10 games again given the upgraded competition without Shaw upgrading the O coaching staff to the level of the D staff.