[FarmBoy]

I also felt like McCaffrey was slighted by getting all-purpose honors, as if he were a utility infielder or something like that. I think he deserved two slots -- running back AND all-purpose player. I know sometimes there's an urge to spread the wealth, McCaffrey should've gotten "all the awards," to quote David Shaw.

Agreed. With McAffrey, I think it was done from a motivation to "spread the wealth" but in this situation, I really think it's to throw Penn State a bone. Barkley is clearly a mercurial talent. He's just not as good an RB as Love.

[FarmBoy]

I also felt like McCaffrey was slighted by getting all-purpose honors, as if he were a utility infielder or something like that. I think he deserved two slots -- running back AND all-purpose player. I know sometimes there's an urge to spread the wealth, McCaffrey should've gotten "all the awards," to quote David Shaw.

Agreed. With McAffrey, I think it was done from a motivation to "spread the wealth" but in this situation, I really think it's to throw Penn State a bone. Barkley is clearly a mercurial talent. He's just not as good an RB as Love.