[BostonCard]

You have a good point.  However, I would say that it would be challenging to have a frank discussion about why we didn't offer a player without saying something disparaging about the player, unless you want to take Shaw's point that we didn't take any QB's that year at face value (no, we didn't take any QB's, but we did offer one), or without being vague to the point of unhelpfulness("we didn't offer because we decided to go in a different direction").  Third, of course, as I pointed out, the discussion about Rosen was less a discussion about Rosen than it was a discussion about Shaw.

And lastly, other than the admin, there is no rule about making disparaging comments.  I just pointed out that it's not a good look; it comes across as sour grapes.  But if you feel strongly about the issue, you have every right to post your thoughts.

BC

[BostonCard]

You have a good point.  However, I would say that it would be challenging to have a frank discussion about why we didn't offer a player without saying something disparaging about the player, unless you want to take Shaw's point that we didn't take any QB's that year at face value (no, we didn't take any QB's, but we did offer one), or without being vague to the point of unhelpfulness("we didn't offer because we decided to go in a different direction").  Third, of course, as I pointed out, the discussion about Rosen was less a discussion about Rosen than it was a discussion about Shaw.

And lastly, other than the admin, there is no rule about making disparaging comments.  I just pointed out that it's not a good look; it comes across as sour grapes.  But if you feel strongly about the issue, you have every right to post your thoughts.

BC