[winflop]

[quote author=winflop link=topic=18698.msg223487#msg223487 date=1518140765]
Once again we are seeing the impact of NOT recruiting a scholarship QB in EVERY SINGLE YEAR...stuff happens

Except in this case, had we taken Josh Rosen 3 years ago, we would have had 1 QB every single year, and not prevented this problem.
Chryst: Completed 4 years in program would still be transferring
Rosen: (would be) Completed 3 years in program would be going pro
Costello: Completed 2 years in program would still be injured (unless he injured himself playing against TCU)
West: Completed 1 year in program would still be injured

Bottom line, we would still be going into Spring with no healthy quarterbacks.

That being said, I agree with your point.

BC
[/quote]

Is it clear Rosen would've been the QB 3 years ago? Not clear to me Shaw would've offered him and it may have been someone else. We will never know.

Even if it had been Rosen, only one of Rosen or Costello would have played last season. If Rosen had played, then Costello would not have been injured, not needed surgery, and would be available for spring ball.

[winflop]

[quote author=winflop link=topic=18698.msg223487#msg223487 date=1518140765]
Once again we are seeing the impact of NOT recruiting a scholarship QB in EVERY SINGLE YEAR...stuff happens

Except in this case, had we taken Josh Rosen 3 years ago, we would have had 1 QB every single year, and not prevented this problem.
Chryst: Completed 4 years in program would still be transferring
Rosen: (would be) Completed 3 years in program would be going pro
Costello: Completed 2 years in program would still be injured (unless he injured himself playing against TCU)
West: Completed 1 year in program would still be injured

Bottom line, we would still be going into Spring with no healthy quarterbacks.

That being said, I agree with your point.

BC
[/quote]

Is it clear Rosen would've been the QB 3 years ago? Not clear to me Shaw would've offered him and it may have been someone else. We will never know.

Even if it had been Rosen, only one of Rosen or Costello would have played last season. If Rosen had played, then Costello would not have been injured, not needed surgery, and would be available for spring ball.