[doug]

dabigv, I wasn't saying I think Josh is capable of being a play-maker, only that I cannot yet conclude with reasonable certainty that he is not. In truth, I doubt he is the play-maker we need at QB and I wish Nottingham or others had been given a chance in light of our lack of offensive production.

But as to Arizona, stats support your characterization of AZ's defense, but Josh threw several well-thrown balls requiring good touch to receivers who were pretty well covered, which surprised me given what I had previously seen.

[doug]

dabigv, I wasn't saying I think Josh is capable of being a play-maker, only that I cannot yet conclude with reasonable certainty that he is not. In truth, I doubt he is the play-maker we need at QB and I wish Nottingham or others had been given a chance in light of our lack of offensive production.

But as to Arizona, stats support your characterization of AZ's defense, but Josh threw several well-thrown balls requiring good touch to receivers who were pretty well covered, which surprised me given what I had previously seen.