[Bruce Wang]

In my opinion, it's CMac.  How do you not win the Voldemort trophy after breaking the yardage record? My guess is that Henry's backup probably could have put up some impressive numbers.  Take him away, and Alabama is pretty much the same team.  I would put Watson ahead of him.

There's a reason Voldemort winners usually underperform in the NFL.  It doesn't go to the best college football player.  It goes to the best player on the best team.

[Bruce Wang]

In my opinion, it's CMac.  How do you not win the Voldemort trophy after breaking the yardage record? My guess is that Henry's backup probably could have put up some impressive numbers.  Take him away, and Alabama is pretty much the same team.  I would put Watson ahead of him.

There's a reason Voldemort winners usually underperform in the NFL.  It doesn't go to the best college football player.  It goes to the best player on the best team.

[JJJ]

Hear, hear!
And after watching the show (recorded), I don't deny that Henry is a good kid with great values and attitude. I applaud him for all he's been through and all he's done. However, Christian McCaffrey had the most outstanding season. Obviously, many of the voters were not aware of the ways (noted on this board) he impacted games--kickers kicking away, defenses selling out and loading the box, shadowing him, etc--and STILL breaking Barry Sanders' record.
I hope he has a MONSTER game on January 1 and make the wrong-voters regret their decisions (although they are probably too dense to notice).

[JJJ]

Hear, hear!
And after watching the show (recorded), I don't deny that Henry is a good kid with great values and attitude. I applaud him for all he's been through and all he's done. However, Christian McCaffrey had the most outstanding season. Obviously, many of the voters were not aware of the ways (noted on this board) he impacted games--kickers kicking away, defenses selling out and loading the box, shadowing him, etc--and STILL breaking Barry Sanders' record.
I hope he has a MONSTER game on January 1 and make the wrong-voters regret their decisions (although they are probably too dense to notice).