The CardBoard
FB Transfer Detransfers - Printable Version

+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: FB Transfer Detransfers (/thread-23948.html)

Pages: 1 2

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - BostonCard - 01-09-2023

(01-09-2023, 11:50 AM)TrumpCard Wrote:  Does kal even have better housing than Stanford?  Maybe just for football players?

That was my first reaction.  I never thought Cal was all that well known for its luxurious housing.  It is entirely possible that moving from Tennessee to Stanford was a very big step down in terms of housing, and that the grass was not as green at Stanford as he expected.

BC

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - cardcrimson - 01-09-2023

(01-09-2023, 11:59 AM)BostonCard Wrote:  
(01-09-2023, 11:50 AM)TrumpCard Wrote:  Does kal even have better housing than Stanford?  Maybe just for football players?

That was my first reaction.  I never thought Cal was all that well known for its luxurious housing.  It is entirely possible that moving from Tennessee to Stanford was a very big step down in terms of housing, and that the grass was not as green at Stanford as he expected.

BC

Was on Alabama's campus for the first time in years over the holidays. Many student housing facilities and the greek system have been substantially updated, and in many instances, completely rebuilt. They are stunning, at least from the outside. A quick perusal of what's offered for athletes is pretty amazing. I'd imagine Tennessee is close to that level. Stanford, I think, has significantly upgraded housing since I was last there in the early 80's, and imaging many are very nice, too. Who knows how close to the level for SEC athletes, though.

That said, do we really want an athlete to whom his or her living facilities are a key factor?

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - DocSavage87 - 01-09-2023

(01-09-2023, 11:44 AM)BostonCard Wrote:  According to this link: https://www.univstats.com/colleges/stanford-university/ask/?question=what-is-the-transfer-out-rate-at-stanford-university

11 students transferred out of Stanford last year.  While every year a number of freshmen don't like their rooms and/or roommates (I didn't love my one room double that had been converted from a single, and I didn't exactly love my roommate), very few students transfer out because of it.

BC

My guess is that family issues, being home sick, or personal entanglements are the main cause. I'm pretty sure you can force a room change, at least back in the day.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - OutsiderFan - 01-11-2023

Someone told me the day JWT dropped out of the Stanford group chat he was in, just happened to be the same day the University of Tennessee released Fall Semester grades. IOW, it seems he was admitted conditionally and had to meet a certain GPA to be fully accepted, and when he didn't his admission was denied.

Yes, Stanford's Football program announced the transfer (giving reason to believe all was on track), but this is the first time such a transfer was allowed, and also - and I think importantly - with a brand new Head Football Coach with no Stanford experience in charge.

I never bought the dorm reason was why he decide to end up in Berkeley. So I went back to why so many other committed recruits have suddenly dropped Stanford. I asked someone in the know, and this is what I was told. Makes the most sense of any reason. No committed recruit ever comes out and says "I was denied Stanford admission." Why would a transfer like JWT be any different?

Y'all can discuss the implications of admissions blowing up a transfer, but I think admissions is responsible for JWT not enrolling at Stanford.  I do find it curious he ended up at Cal given Cal has more RB depth than Stanford. Maybe he just wants to play for a school that values academics more than winning football games.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - Phogge - 01-11-2023

Stanford has a D2 program. All about talent level.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - Mick - 01-11-2023

The few times I've seen Cal housing, I wasn't very impressed. Stanford's housing was pretty good, by comparison

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - SamuelMcF - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 11:26 AM)OutsiderFan Wrote:  Y'all can discuss the implications of admissions blowing up a transfer, but I think admissions is responsible for JWT not enrolling at Stanford.  I do find it curious he ended up at Cal given Cal has more RB depth than Stanford. Maybe he just wants to play for a school that values academics more than winning football games.

Cal's RB room is Jadyn Ott and...nobody. They had 4 RBs leave via the portal.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - OutsiderFan - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 12:04 PM)SamuelMcF Wrote:  
(01-11-2023, 11:26 AM)OutsiderFan Wrote:  Y'all can discuss the implications of admissions blowing up a transfer, but I think admissions is responsible for JWT not enrolling at Stanford.  I do find it curious he ended up at Cal given Cal has more RB depth than Stanford. Maybe he just wants to play for a school that values academics more than winning football games.

Cal's RB room is Jadyn Ott and...nobody. They had 4 RBs leave via the portal.

The Cal fan consensus was that they have a deep RB room, in part because of other transfers.  But FFS, Cal is not what should be being talked about here, because Cal has nothing to do with why JWT isn't enrolling at Stanford.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - BobK - 01-11-2023

It seems that the dorm issue was the reason especially rooming with a non athlete. From those in the know

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - 81alum - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 12:32 PM)BobK Wrote:  It seems that the dorm issue was the reason especially rooming with a non athlete.  From those in the know
Interesting.  That has long been the Stanford way--my dorm room was next door to a football player who was rooming with a non-athlete friend of mine his freshman year.  I think it was an effort to keep athletes integrated into the general student body and not (as many universities do) segregate them into athletic dorms.  But while that may work for freshmen, I wonder how it would work for transfer students.  And I also wonder whether Stanford's policies on living arrangements have evolved since I was there.  More recently I know many athletes seem to live off campus with teammates once they have been around a year or two.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - 82lsju - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 01:09 PM)81alum Wrote:  
(01-11-2023, 12:32 PM)BobK Wrote:  It seems that the dorm issue was the reason especially rooming with a non athlete.  From those in the know
Interesting.  That has long been the Stanford way--my dorm room was next door to a football player who was rooming with a non-athlete friend of mine his freshman year.  I think it was an effort to keep athletes integrated into the general student body and not (as many universities do) segregate them into athletic dorms.  But while that may work for freshmen, I wonder how it would work for transfer students.  And I also wonder whether Stanford's policies on living arrangements have evolved since I was there.  More recently I know many athletes seem to live off campus with teammates once they have been around a year or two.

and entering in Winter Quarter would provide more challenges as the transfer has to be slotted into an existing space, the likelihood of that being another athlete is probably low, the likelihood of a double opening up and putting two football transfers in it also seems low.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - OutsiderFan - 01-11-2023

Still not buying the dorm reason. JWT has pushed that narrative hard from what I've been told.

As someone who was a mid-year undergrad transfer and graduate school transfer, I can certainly relate to the challenges of fitting in to a new campus when everyone has already had a chance to meet and develop relationships. And I don't remember roommate change requests being denied, because when things get to that point, the request probably has merit. 

Changing schools because of a living situation just is not a believable reason to me, or the person who told me about the grade release timing. You don't base your decision to be at a school on with whom or where you are living. You just don't. You make it based on the school, campus, the program you are in, the teachers (coaches). You don't decide to transfer somewhere, then pick another school because you don't like your living situation.

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - BobK - 01-11-2023

The truth is out there OF. Hard for me to believe also. But sources are very good

RE: FB Transfer Detransfers - cardcrimson - 01-11-2023

(01-11-2023, 06:09 PM)OutsiderFan Wrote:  You don't base your decision to be at a school on with whom or where you are living. You just don't. You make it based on the school, campus, the program you are in, the teachers (coaches). You don't decide to transfer somewhere, then pick another school because you don't like your living situation.

Thanks for clearing that up. Then what, pray tell was the reason? Enquiring minds want to know.