The CardBoard
To renew or not to renew... - Printable Version

+- The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board)
+-- Forum: C-House! (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: The CardBoard (https://thecardboard.org/board/forum-5.html)
+--- Thread: To renew or not to renew... (/thread-23200.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5

To renew or not to renew... - CardinalSagehen - 05-12-2022

Renewal Deadline, Stanford Football, tomorrow 5/13!

"To be (renew), or not to be (cancel): that is the question.
Whether ’tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune (can't run the ball or stop the run),
Or to take arms against a sea of troubles,
And by opposing end them? To die (cancel): to sleep;
No more; and by a sleep to say we end
The heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks..."

I am torn. On the one hand, we now have the seats I always wanted - Sec. 116 on the 115 side (around the 10 or 15 yard-line, but as close to midfield as you can get without a big donation); and a high row so we have perspective and we're in the shade quickly in the afternoon. On the other hand, it's $1K for the three of us, and with our team looking as it does, I don't think these tix will be hard to get! 

Maybe I should hedge and downgrade back to the Family Plan?  Or "sleep" and "end the heart-ache"?

What have others done?

RE: To renew or not to renew... - terry - 05-12-2022

I renewed. I've kept my tickets through hard times in the past. I'm not ready to drop them yet.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - old spanish trail - 05-12-2022

(05-12-2022, 05:30 PM)terry Wrote:  I renewed. I've kept my tickets through hard times in the past. I'm not ready to drop them yet.

We will wait till next year. Liked our seats, but all friends gone.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - winflop - 05-12-2022

I kept my tickets through IdiotFace and HeWhoMustNotBeNamed. This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years. There are better days ahead, one way or another.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - PAsportsfan - 05-12-2022

I struggled with the same question but renewed my four seats. I should have dropped two of them as they are hard to find takers/sell.

If your WHOLE group doesn’t mind squatting in random seats, it doesn’t make sense financially to have season seats.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - Phogge - 05-12-2022

First game in 1953. Got to be a burden in multiple ways. Found that I didn’t miss it last year. TV is good enough.

All things must end one way or the other (The Reaper).

RE: To renew or not to renew... - PVTree - 05-12-2022

I got a call from Stanford about 3 weeks ago reminding me to renew. I told the agent that I was planning to renew but that didn't mean that I was happy with the product and that I know a few people who are not renewing because of this reason.

We spoke for a good 15 minutes, mainly me complaining that the team stayed put despite being blown out in the last few games of the year, that we need an OC, and the agent just nodding to everything I said.

Today I renewed and the same agent, not knowing that I renewed, called me again to remind me about the deadline. I told him that his call came an hour late since I already renewed, but was still not happy that there were no changes... That I don't want to hear gums yapping, I want to see change on the field. He told me that he trusts that there will be significant changes based on what he has heard from others at DAPER. We ended the call with me telling him that I hope so because it is getting harder to renew with such a boring product on the field.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - Snorlax94 - 05-13-2022

I renewed pretty much the first day it was available — and I am moving out of state but will fly in for a few games per season and sell the rest to interested parties.

I say Renew!

Ps - i am in Section 116! Love it, just wish better food options were closer.

Pps - what is DAPER?

RE: To renew or not to renew... - BostonCard - 05-13-2022

Department of Athletics, Physical Education, and Recreation.

BC

RE: To renew or not to renew... - gailtate - 05-13-2022

(05-12-2022, 05:53 PM)winflop Wrote:  I kept my tickets through IdiotFace and HeWhoMustNotBeNamed. This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years. There are better days ahead, one way or another.

"This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years."  Oh, no? I beg to differ. This isn't about attendance numbers, this is about performance. Or lack thereof. I respectfully submit that "This", defined as the 2019 season, last season and the dismal prospects of the upcoming one, is not only "as bad", it is worse. It is historically bad. Categorically bad. Hang-down-your-head-Tom Dooley-bad. The Mother of All Nadirs. As for said attendance, numbers in the low-teens is a distinct possibility in 2022 as the weather turns and the losses pile up.  Just you wait, Henry Higgins, just you wait.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - 82lsju - 05-13-2022

(05-13-2022, 08:11 AM)gailtate Wrote:  As for said attendance, numbers in the low-teens is a distinct possibility in 2022 as the weather turns and the losses pile up.  Just you wait, Henry Higgins, just you wait.

you won't have to wait until late in the season, I'm pretty sure the Colgate game will have poor attendance (especially with my expectation of an 8pm PT kick-off), from our group I'd estimate at most 4 or 20 people (who now have only 16 tix between them) will attend that game....

RE: To renew or not to renew... - qwerty49 - 05-13-2022

Tough decision.  STH for 48 years.  But now I live in SoCal and can usually only make 1 game a year.  The night games require an overnight stay and the other kickoffs are decided too late in the cycle to get the best air fares.  Daughter no longer lives in the Bay Area and both of my longtime seatmates have passed on.  

I think if I want to make a game, I can find one ticket on StubHub easily.   And the people around me in Row A of 235 won't have to sit next to Domers every other Thanksgiving.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - winflop - 05-13-2022

(05-13-2022, 08:11 AM)gailtate Wrote:  
(05-12-2022, 05:53 PM)winflop Wrote:  I kept my tickets through IdiotFace and HeWhoMustNotBeNamed. This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years. There are better days ahead, one way or another.

"This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years."  Oh, no? I beg to differ. This isn't about attendance numbers, this is about performance. Or lack thereof. I respectfully submit that "This", defined as the 2019 season, last season and the dismal prospects of the upcoming one, is not only "as bad", it is worse. It is historically bad. Categorically bad. Hang-down-your-head-Tom Dooley-bad. The Mother of All Nadirs. As for said attendance, numbers in the low-teens is a distinct possibility in 2022 as the weather turns and the losses pile up.  Just you wait, Henry Higgins, just you wait.

Stanford football 2002-2006: 16-40 overall (.285), 10-31 Pac-12 (.243)
Stanford football 2019 & 2021: 7-17 (.291), 5-13 in Pac-12 (.278)

So the era of which I speak was a lot like 2019 & 2020, but it last FIVE STINKIN YEARS. So yeah, it was worse than what we are dealing with now.

I can't imagine that three more seasons with 4 or fewer wins would be tolerated, even by a spineless storeminder like Muir.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - qwerty49 - 05-13-2022

(05-13-2022, 02:50 PM)winflop Wrote:  
(05-13-2022, 08:11 AM)gailtate Wrote:  
(05-12-2022, 05:53 PM)winflop Wrote:  I kept my tickets through IdiotFace and HeWhoMustNotBeNamed. This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years. There are better days ahead, one way or another.

"This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years."  Oh, no? I beg to differ. This isn't about attendance numbers, this is about performance. Or lack thereof. I respectfully submit that "This", defined as the 2019 season, last season and the dismal prospects of the upcoming one, is not only "as bad", it is worse. It is historically bad. Categorically bad. Hang-down-your-head-Tom Dooley-bad. The Mother of All Nadirs. As for said attendance, numbers in the low-teens is a distinct possibility in 2022 as the weather turns and the losses pile up.  Just you wait, Henry Higgins, just you wait.

Stanford football 2002-2006: 16-40 overall (.285), 10-31 Pac-12 (.243)
Stanford football 2019 & 2021: 7-17 (.291), 5-13 in Pac-12 (.278)

So the era of which I speak was a lot like 2019 & 2020, but it last FIVE STINKIN YEARS. So yeah, it was worse than what we are dealing with now.

I can't imagine that three more seasons with 4 or fewer wins would be tolerated, even by a spineless storeminder like Muir.

3 more 4-win seasons would be a no-brainer.  But 1 or 2 would be an interesting over-under proposition.  I think both Muir and Shaw are in the well-paid comfort zone of "neither wanting nor needing to" rock the boat.  Spine is not really a consideration.  And in what universe would Muir be the sole decision-maker anyway?

RE: To renew or not to renew... - McKenwood - 05-13-2022

Just told my AD minder I will not be renewing. Good guy so I felt bad telling him the news. Got an immediate email from someone on the development side. I told him that I wanted to hear from Shaw and Muir what they were doing to make it better. Those two need to convince me that is worth spending $100s of dollars per seat (when the non-deductible) contributions are factored in. Last year seats were available in my section for $25 per game on Stubhub. I suspect they will be cheaper this season.

Last time I didn't renew was after the 2005 season. Took awhile but the program took off to levels not even I could have imagined including two Rose Bowls wins and the epic AL win over SC in the Coliseum. So I am grateful for all of that but I don't like supporting a program where I feel more invested than some of the people running it.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - terry - 05-13-2022

(05-13-2022, 02:50 PM)winflop Wrote:  Stanford football 2002-2006: 16-40 overall (.285), 10-31 Pac-12 (.243)
Stanford football 2019 & 2021: 7-17 (.291), 5-13 in Pac-12 (.278)

So the era of which I speak was a lot like 2019 & 2020, but it last FIVE STINKIN YEARS. So yeah, it was worse than what we are dealing with now.

I can't imagine that three more seasons with 4 or fewer wins would be tolerated, even by a spineless storeminder like Muir.

These figures skipped the 2020 season. Those games happened. I don't think they should be ignored.

Including 2020, Stanford's record for the last three years was:

2019-2021 -- Overall 11-19 (.367), 9-15 in Pac-12 (.375)

RE: To renew or not to renew... - gailtate - 05-13-2022

(05-13-2022, 02:50 PM)winflop Wrote:  
(05-13-2022, 08:11 AM)gailtate Wrote:  
(05-12-2022, 05:53 PM)winflop Wrote:  I kept my tickets through IdiotFace and HeWhoMustNotBeNamed. This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years. There are better days ahead, one way or another.

"This is nowhere near as bad as those 5 years."  Oh, no? I beg to differ. This isn't about attendance numbers, this is about performance. Or lack thereof. I respectfully submit that "This", defined as the 2019 season, last season and the dismal prospects of the upcoming one, is not only "as bad", it is worse. It is historically bad. Categorically bad. Hang-down-your-head-Tom Dooley-bad. The Mother of All Nadirs. As for said attendance, numbers in the low-teens is a distinct possibility in 2022 as the weather turns and the losses pile up.  Just you wait, Henry Higgins, just you wait.

Stanford football 2002-2006: 16-40 overall (.285), 10-31 Pac-12 (.243)
Stanford football 2019 & 2021: 7-17 (.291), 5-13 in Pac-12 (.278)

So the era of which I speak was a lot like 2019 & 2020, but it last FIVE STINKIN YEARS. So yeah, it was worse than what we are dealing with now.

I can't imagine that three more seasons with 4 or fewer wins would be tolerated, even by a spineless storeminder like Muir.

"...it was worse than what we are dealing with now..."  Nope, hairsplitting not allowed. Here's why: the ham-handed losses sustained after the 2018 scoop-and-score Oregon game (despite the Sun Bowl win), combined with mis-managed recruitment when the process was changing, plus the dog-vomit 2019 season and the disaster of post-pandemic (mostly) 2021 was the prelude to the utter hopelessness we're looking at today compared to 2007 when we got an epic infusion of hope for the football program. Today there is no such hope. It's in shorter supply than baby formula. We're stuck with Weekends at Bernie's for the duration of Shaw: several more years of trials and tribulations. Don't bask in marginal superiority over BuddyWlat-ism. It's a low bar.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - CardinalSagehen - 05-14-2022

It’s done.  I renewed.  Thank you, Snorlax and others, for the reassurance.  It may be irrational economically, but that does not mean it must not be done.  

‘Tis nobler.  For me.  I guess.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - gailtate - 05-14-2022

(05-13-2022, 03:52 PM)McKenwood Wrote:  Just told my AD minder I will not be renewing. Good guy so I felt bad telling him the news. Got an immediate email from someone on the development side. I told him that I wanted to hear from Shaw and Muir what they were doing to make it better. Those two need to convince me that is worth spending $100s of dollars per seat (when the non-deductible) contributions are factored in. Last year seats were available in my section for $25 per game on Stubhub. I suspect they will be cheaper this season.

Last time I didn't renew was after the 2005 season. Took awhile but the program took off to levels not even I could have imagined including two Rose Bowls wins and the epic AL win over SC in the Coliseum. So I am grateful for all of that but I don't like supporting a program where I feel more invested than some of the people running it.

"I don't like supporting a program where I feel more invested than some of the people running it."
Hammer, say hello to nail!  The sentence above captures the exasperation of many. Thanks for the distillation, McKenwood.

RE: To renew or not to renew... - Treebound - 05-14-2022

I renewed as well, but moved our group to a section without the PSL/gift.  Too many alums that I buy for were going to leave altogether if we stayed in the more expensive seats.  I think the fallout will be big this year.   If the 3-4 win trajectory continues, the stadium will become even more of a cavern.  I still can't believe there were zero changes to the staff last year.   The seats for some in the AD should be very hot by now.   To have both football and basketball in the doldrums is not a good sign.