[BostonCard]

Bryce wasn’t robbed. Mayfield was dynamic on a better team. He made them better. But it was close. Andrew wasn’t robbed in Newton’s year except by the Auburn/Daddy Newton recruiting nightmare.

However Toby, McCaffrey and Andrew in Griffin’s year were robbed.

Hey, they're our guys... Of course they were robbed!  J/K I think that is a fair objective assessment.  From most to least deserving (in their year):

McCaffrey (2015)
Gerhart (2009)
Luck (2011)
Love (2017)
Luck (2010 - his better year, but can't really begrudge the year Newton had)

BC

[BostonCard]

Bryce wasn’t robbed. Mayfield was dynamic on a better team. He made them better. But it was close. Andrew wasn’t robbed in Newton’s year except by the Auburn/Daddy Newton recruiting nightmare.

However Toby, McCaffrey and Andrew in Griffin’s year were robbed.

Hey, they're our guys... Of course they were robbed!  J/K I think that is a fair objective assessment.  From most to least deserving (in their year):

McCaffrey (2015)
Gerhart (2009)
Luck (2011)
Love (2017)
Luck (2010 - his better year, but can't really begrudge the year Newton had)

BC