[JohnR34231]

If Smith does stay Costello has perhaps the best all round receiving corps in the country. Mackey finalist TE, giant flex TE, two veteran soph WR’s, a speed slot guy, a proven RB receiver and two promising frosh.

However if Costello were to pull the pin there would be nobody with experience to get them the ball.

I don’t care if Butter was sub par in the State title game. He was spot-on on the last drive to win. He has had an outstanding year against very good competition. Shaw needs two QB’s next year even if McKee doesn’t pull a Taysom Hill. If there is a better option OK. The kid wants to come, is a QB legacy.

Did I miss something or isn't Butterfield a 2020 recruit?  If so, even if Smith stays this year, he will have exhausted his eligibility after 2019 and will definitely be in the NFL.  Not sure what Parkinson will do.

I'm not sure that I would call Wilson and St. Brown "veteran sophomore wide receivers" as they played sparingly.  Hopefully by the time 2020 rolls around, they will be "veteran junior WR's"


BC

I think TC was talking about Costello throwing to Smith, not Butterfield.
Whether Wilson or St. Brown are veterans or not depends on how you define the term. I'm not sure they are rookies either. Perhaps somewhere in between.

[JohnR34231]

If Smith does stay Costello has perhaps the best all round receiving corps in the country. Mackey finalist TE, giant flex TE, two veteran soph WR’s, a speed slot guy, a proven RB receiver and two promising frosh.

However if Costello were to pull the pin there would be nobody with experience to get them the ball.

I don’t care if Butter was sub par in the State title game. He was spot-on on the last drive to win. He has had an outstanding year against very good competition. Shaw needs two QB’s next year even if McKee doesn’t pull a Taysom Hill. If there is a better option OK. The kid wants to come, is a QB legacy.

Did I miss something or isn't Butterfield a 2020 recruit?  If so, even if Smith stays this year, he will have exhausted his eligibility after 2019 and will definitely be in the NFL.  Not sure what Parkinson will do.

I'm not sure that I would call Wilson and St. Brown "veteran sophomore wide receivers" as they played sparingly.  Hopefully by the time 2020 rolls around, they will be "veteran junior WR's"


BC

I think TC was talking about Costello throwing to Smith, not Butterfield.
Whether Wilson or St. Brown are veterans or not depends on how you define the term. I'm not sure they are rookies either. Perhaps somewhere in between.