[Mick]

Collins before 1950 so no Wilhelm
no

Yes on Williams and Newson

Wilhelm didn't make the majors until he was 29.  And in his rookie season with the Giants, he went 15-3, finished 4th in MVP voting.

Here's a question: Which MLB Hall of Famer made the fewest all-star teams, while playing exclusively in the All-Star game era? (post-1933).

[Mick]

Collins before 1950 so no Wilhelm
no

Yes on Williams and Newson

Wilhelm didn't make the majors until he was 29.  And in his rookie season with the Giants, he went 15-3, finished 4th in MVP voting.

Here's a question: Which MLB Hall of Famer made the fewest all-star teams, while playing exclusively in the All-Star game era? (post-1933).