[spike5882]

We have yet to see a trans athlete change gender with the purpose to create an advantage.  

Perhaps not. However, Lia is certainly capitalizing on that advantage, isn't she. Six foot five, broad shoulders, 15+ years training and competing as a guy. . . .

When does it become not okay? When a trans girl maims or kills a cisgender girl in a contact sport?

Good lord.  You make it sound like hordes of football players are running to their doctors to transition. A pretty far fetched perspective you have. In your world, pretty soon all these males will be infiltrating all of women sports, maiming and killing other girls along the way, so they can more easily win and finally get paid since they weren’t good enough as a male. But wait, there’s no money in women’s sports. Hmm. So what actually would be their motivation…a ribbon, a medal, a trophy? Genuine question.

And how exactly is she capitalizing on transitioning? I don’t see her taking advantage of anything since she has transitioned; she has just swam and been pretty quiet about it. Has she gotten tons of endorsements or NIL money? Another genuine question. Just how is she capitalizing?

[spike5882]

We have yet to see a trans athlete change gender with the purpose to create an advantage.  

Perhaps not. However, Lia is certainly capitalizing on that advantage, isn't she. Six foot five, broad shoulders, 15+ years training and competing as a guy. . . .

When does it become not okay? When a trans girl maims or kills a cisgender girl in a contact sport?

Good lord.  You make it sound like hordes of football players are running to their doctors to transition. A pretty far fetched perspective you have. In your world, pretty soon all these males will be infiltrating all of women sports, maiming and killing other girls along the way, so they can more easily win and finally get paid since they weren’t good enough as a male. But wait, there’s no money in women’s sports. Hmm. So what actually would be their motivation…a ribbon, a medal, a trophy? Genuine question.

And how exactly is she capitalizing on transitioning? I don’t see her taking advantage of anything since she has transitioned; she has just swam and been pretty quiet about it. Has she gotten tons of endorsements or NIL money? Another genuine question. Just how is she capitalizing?