[washingtonismoney]

Here are some of the reviews of Jason Garrett from last year as an offensive coordinator: 

New York’s response to the loss was to fire offensive coordinator Jason Garrett. There is zero question this was the right decision. An offense is supposed to score touchdowns—and since Garrett was hired in 2020, the Giants have ranked dead last in offensive touchdowns. In case that wasn’t reason enough for him to be dismissed, the loss to the Bucs was Garrett’s Bizarro masterpiece: bad play-calling, sloppy execution, and a lack of vision for how to put players in positions to succeed. The Giants offense is predictable, sloppy, and unimaginative.

Includes roasting Garrett for not getting play calls in quickly enough -- one of the biggest peeves everyone had with the Shaw offense. https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2021/11/23...-scapegoat

More reviews of Garrett from last year; https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/giant...-new-york/

Could go on and on! He just wasn't a very good coach at the NFL level and has few qualities that would make you think he's a better fit in college, unless you have strong views about why Stanford players should be coached by fellow smart guys. (A view decisively refuted by Harbaugh, Ralston, etc.)

---

At least can we all agree this is an upgrade over Shaw?

Shaw is a better coach than Garrett. I think this is a downgrade.

[washingtonismoney]

Here are some of the reviews of Jason Garrett from last year as an offensive coordinator: 

New York’s response to the loss was to fire offensive coordinator Jason Garrett. There is zero question this was the right decision. An offense is supposed to score touchdowns—and since Garrett was hired in 2020, the Giants have ranked dead last in offensive touchdowns. In case that wasn’t reason enough for him to be dismissed, the loss to the Bucs was Garrett’s Bizarro masterpiece: bad play-calling, sloppy execution, and a lack of vision for how to put players in positions to succeed. The Giants offense is predictable, sloppy, and unimaginative.

Includes roasting Garrett for not getting play calls in quickly enough -- one of the biggest peeves everyone had with the Shaw offense. https://www.theringer.com/nfl/2021/11/23...-scapegoat

More reviews of Garrett from last year; https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/news/giant...-new-york/

Could go on and on! He just wasn't a very good coach at the NFL level and has few qualities that would make you think he's a better fit in college, unless you have strong views about why Stanford players should be coached by fellow smart guys. (A view decisively refuted by Harbaugh, Ralston, etc.)

---

At least can we all agree this is an upgrade over Shaw?

Shaw is a better coach than Garrett. I think this is a downgrade.