[dabigv13]

The term lynch law refers to a self-constituted court that imposes sentence on a person without due process of law

(britannica.com)

Some are calling to remove him from his position before an investigation is completed. You have clearly made up your mind about the outcome before that. 

On December 5, I pointed out the (prior) PubPeer discussions on these issues.  I don’t recall that others have ever mentioned them. Is all your information from the news media?

I know what a lynch mob is, you don't need to cite Britannica. This is about a man who can't do his job, because of the scandal his past misconduct has brought, and should be replaced. No one is hanging MTL or putting him in a jail cell. He is not entitled to be a university president by law. As previously noted, he is not the King of Stanford.

MTL is not being charged or investigated for a crime. Whatever investigation the university does will not have the force of subpoena. It will not reach any definitive conclusions. They won't find a smoking gun email from MTL to his postdoc telling him to make up the experiment.

MTL has been investigated. The Daily has multiple corroborating accounts. Again I ask, do you think this is a conspiracy whisper campaign to bring down MTL for whatever purpose? Are all these ex Genentech execs lying?

I read the PubPeer discussions back in December. Do you think there is something exculpatory there? Is there something there that contradicts the reporting of the Daily?

[dabigv13]

The term lynch law refers to a self-constituted court that imposes sentence on a person without due process of law

(britannica.com)

Some are calling to remove him from his position before an investigation is completed. You have clearly made up your mind about the outcome before that. 

On December 5, I pointed out the (prior) PubPeer discussions on these issues.  I don’t recall that others have ever mentioned them. Is all your information from the news media?

I know what a lynch mob is, you don't need to cite Britannica. This is about a man who can't do his job, because of the scandal his past misconduct has brought, and should be replaced. No one is hanging MTL or putting him in a jail cell. He is not entitled to be a university president by law. As previously noted, he is not the King of Stanford.

MTL is not being charged or investigated for a crime. Whatever investigation the university does will not have the force of subpoena. It will not reach any definitive conclusions. They won't find a smoking gun email from MTL to his postdoc telling him to make up the experiment.

MTL has been investigated. The Daily has multiple corroborating accounts. Again I ask, do you think this is a conspiracy whisper campaign to bring down MTL for whatever purpose? Are all these ex Genentech execs lying?

I read the PubPeer discussions back in December. Do you think there is something exculpatory there? Is there something there that contradicts the reporting of the Daily?