(05-19-2023, 12:49 AM)JJJ Wrote: (05-18-2023, 11:47 PM)Brickcity Wrote: (05-18-2023, 11:20 PM)PVTree Wrote: I'm beginning to think shortstop is our weakest link. Not much hitting, which is ok if it was made up by a sterling glove, but that's not the case.
Cobb is hitting .330 on the year. Yeah, he's a little shaky in the field but he's hit well for us.
I don’t have a screenshot but they had a graphic recently comparing Cobb to Crampton. We were spoiled by Crampton’s stellar D. And I think Cobb is fantastic this year but don’t see how it was an E1 when Cobb couldn’t hang on to the throw on a sac bunt attempt. He should’ve pretended he was a first baseman and stretched away from the bag to make the catch.
A few posts above (last Monday) I gave a comparison of the two.
Quote:Cobb 2023 vs Crampton 2022 is an interesting comparison.
Cobb is better offensively, Crampton was better defensively.
Cobb 2023: 0.337 AVG; 0.503 SLG; 0.625 RBI/gm; 6 HR || 0.919 FLD; 14 errors (48 games - "leads" Pac 12)
Crampton 22: 0.316 AVG; 0.392 SLG; 0.615 RBI/gm; 1 HR || 0.980 FLD; 5 errors (65 games)
While I think the analytics guys' mantra was "defense doesn't matter", maybe it does for a shortstop.
A bit more.
Cobb 2023 is better offensively than Crampton 2022 largely due to power.
Be careful with how much weight you give to RBIs. That is partially a measure of things to care about (like clutch hitting) but also partially a measure of what the people in front of you in the order are doing. Cobb has hit in the #9 spot basically all season. The #8 spot has been troublesome (DH). The #7 spot has been whomever among our big sluggers is struggling the most.
Defensively, Cobb is kind of the anti-Crampton. Crampton became well known as a guy who didn't make many spectacular plays but didn't miss routine plays. His 5 errors last year were quite low for a short stop. Cobb has made several plays bordering on the spectacular, including a very nice play last night in the bottom of the seventh on the ball that bounced off Bowser's glove. But, Cobb makes a lot of errors (14 so far), and a lot of plays that aren't quite errors but miss a chance for an out (for example, a few times I have seen him be quite slow getting a throw off to Bowser that negates a possible double play).
Anyway, the comparison isn't all that meaningful. It's not as if Crampton was benched in favor of Cobb.
Rather than focusing on his shortcomings, I'd rather note that after three years of not being able to hold a starting job due to his hitting Cobb did a tremendous job improving at the plate so he could be a strong contributor this year.
Finally - on the scoring of the Dowd to Cobb throw. From what I have seen, most scorers will tend to give the error to the throw when there is a throw vs catch error question. So, this is typical. It resembles the scoring decision in the play that gave Stanford softball their quarterfinal win over Oregon, where the error was given to the 2B who made an inaccurate throw rather than the 3B whose glove the ball bounced off of.
Dowd has had trouble making throws to the bases this year, with a 0.455 fielding percentage - that's 6 errors in 11 attempts.